TikToker sues Roblox over her Charli XCX ‘Apple’ dance

TikTok content creator Kelley Heyer has filed a lawsuit against Roblox, alleging the unauthorized use of her dance choreography set to Charli XCX’s song “Apple.” Heyer, who posted the viral dance in June 2024, claims Roblox incorporated her choreography into their game without securing her permission, unlike Fortnite, which licensed her dance. According to reports, Roblox sold over 60,000 emotes of the dance, earning an estimated $123,000. In response, Roblox emphasized its commitment to protecting intellectual property rights.
This case highlights ongoing tensions between content creators and digital platforms regarding intellectual property rights and compensation. The legal battle could set a precedent for how user-generated content is monetized in video games, especially as platforms like Roblox and Fortnite continue to integrate popular cultural elements into their gaming experiences. The outcome may also influence future collaborations and licensing agreements between creators and gaming companies, underscoring the importance of clear intellectual property guidelines in the digital age.
RATING
The news story provides a generally accurate and timely account of the legal dispute between Kelley Heyer and Roblox over the use of her viral dance. It effectively highlights key issues related to intellectual property rights and the monetization of digital content, which are of significant public interest. The article presents a balanced view by including perspectives from both Heyer and Roblox, though it could benefit from additional context and expert insights to enhance its depth and transparency. The clarity and readability of the story are strong, making it accessible to a wide audience, while its potential to spark discussion and influence opinions is notable. However, the story could improve by incorporating more detailed background information and diverse sources to strengthen its overall impact and engagement.
RATING DETAILS
The story provides a generally accurate account of the lawsuit involving Kelley Heyer and Roblox over the use of her dance. Key facts such as the lawsuit being filed by Heyer against Roblox for using her choreography without permission are consistent with the information available from multiple sources. The story also accurately describes the involvement of Fortnite, which obtained Heyer's permission, contrasting with Roblox's alleged lack of a licensing agreement. However, there are areas that require further verification, such as the exact timeline of events and the financial details regarding Roblox's earnings from the emotes. While the story mentions that Heyer estimates Roblox earned over $123,000, this claim should be cross-verified with official financial records or statements.
The story presents the perspectives of both Kelley Heyer and Roblox, providing a balanced view of the legal dispute. Heyer's claims about the unauthorized use of her dance are clearly outlined, and Roblox's response regarding their commitment to protecting intellectual property rights is included. However, the article could improve by including more context on the broader implications of intellectual property rights for digital creators. Additionally, insights from legal experts on the potential outcomes of such cases could provide a more rounded perspective.
The article is generally clear and concise, with a straightforward presentation of the facts. The structure follows a logical progression from introducing the lawsuit to detailing the involvement of the parties and the financial implications. The language is neutral and accessible, making the story easy to understand for a general audience. However, the inclusion of more detailed background information on the legal context of intellectual property rights for digital content could enhance comprehension for readers unfamiliar with the topic.
The story references a statement from Roblox, which adds credibility to the report. However, it lacks direct quotes or detailed information from Kelley Heyer or her legal team, which would strengthen the source quality. The reliance on a single statement from Roblox without additional corroborating sources limits the depth of the article. Including input from industry analysts or legal experts would enhance the reliability and authority of the information presented.
The article provides basic context about the lawsuit and the parties involved, but it lacks detailed explanations of the legal and financial aspects of the case. The methodology behind Heyer's financial estimates and the specifics of the licensing negotiations are not disclosed, which affects transparency. Additionally, the article does not clarify whether there are any conflicts of interest or biases that might influence the reporting. Greater transparency in these areas would help readers understand the basis of the claims and the factors impacting the story.
Sources
- https://axs.tv/news-story/creator-behind-viral-charli-xcx-apple-dance-sues-roblox/
- https://www.fastcompany.com/91319398/a-tiktoker-sues-roblox-for-using-her-viral-charli-xcx-dance-without-permission
- https://people.com/apple-dance-creator-is-suing-over-her-viral-choreography-11717486
- https://www.vinylmeplease.com/blogs/music-industry-news/charli-xcx-s-viral-dance-creator-sues-roblox-over-intellectual-property-dispute
YOU MAY BE INTERESTED IN

Airman Posed As Teen On Roblox To Get Sexual Images From Underage Girl: Feds
Score 7.0
Driverless Waymo taxi ‘traps’ passengers while stopped in traffic on one of Austin’s ‘scariest roads’: report
Score 6.2
This Rosemary Oil Gave Reviewers 'Significantly Fuller Hair' And It's Currently On Sale
Score 5.0
She Moved to Italy for a Dream 3-Month Au Pair Job. 5 Days Later, She Was Fleeing Her Host Family (Exclusive)
Score 6.4