White House says it's halting funds to US university over transgender athletes

BBC - Mar 20th, 2025
Open on BBC

The Trump administration has announced the suspension of $175 million in federal funding to the University of Pennsylvania due to the institution's policy on transgender athletes. This decision is linked to the participation of Lia Thomas, a transgender woman who won a national college swimming title in 2022 while competing for UPenn. The funding cut, primarily from the Department of Defense and the Department of Health and Human Services, reflects Trump's broader initiative to limit transgender athlete participation in sports and reduce federal expenditure. UPenn has stated it has not received formal notification of the funding suspension, and the freeze appears to be separate from an ongoing investigation into potential Title IX violations by the university.

This development is part of a larger controversy surrounding transgender athletes in collegiate sports, with the NCAA recently revising its policies to restrict participation to individuals assigned female at birth. The issue has sparked legal challenges, including a lawsuit from three former UPenn swimmers seeking to annul Thomas's records. The funding suspension also comes amid other punitive measures by Trump against institutions like Columbia University and the University of Maine over similar policy disputes. This reflects a significant intersection of sports, federal policy, and transgender rights, highlighting the ongoing debate over gender identity in athletics and its implications for institutional funding and compliance with federal law.

Story submitted by Fairstory

RATING

6.0
Moderately Fair
Read with skepticism

The news story effectively highlights a significant and timely issue involving federal funding, transgender athletes, and educational policies. It presents a clear narrative with relevant context but would benefit from greater source transparency and balance. The reliance on unnamed sources and the lack of detailed verification of certain claims affect its overall accuracy and credibility. Despite these limitations, the story addresses a topic of high public interest and has the potential to influence ongoing debates and policy discussions. The coverage of related events, such as the NCAA policy change and Title IX investigations, adds depth to the narrative, although additional context and explanation would enhance clarity and comprehension for a general audience.

RATING DETAILS

7
Accuracy

The story presents a series of factual claims, such as the Trump administration suspending $175 million in federal funding to the University of Pennsylvania due to policies on transgender athletes. These claims are generally verifiable through official statements and policy documentation, but some aspects require further confirmation. For instance, the story mentions that UPenn has not received official notification of the funding suspension, a claim that should be verified against official communications from relevant government departments. Additionally, the story references a recent NCAA policy change and an executive order by President Trump, both of which are critical to the narrative and need to be cross-checked with official legislative or policy documents. The mention of Lia Thomas's athletic achievements and the impact on women's sports records also requires verification through sports records and NCAA statements.

6
Balance

The story provides perspectives from both the Trump administration and the University of Pennsylvania, offering a degree of balance. However, the narrative leans more towards the administration's viewpoint, especially with the inclusion of a statement from an unnamed Trump official. The article could benefit from more input from transgender athletes or advocacy groups to provide a fuller picture of the implications of the funding suspension. Additionally, while the story mentions the NCAA's policy change, it does not explore the broader context of how these policies affect athletes and universities, potentially leading to an imbalance in perspective.

7
Clarity

The article is generally clear in its presentation of the main events and claims, with a logical flow from the introduction of the funding suspension to the broader implications of the policy changes. However, the inclusion of multiple related events, such as the funding cut to Columbia University and the investigation into the University of Maine, could potentially confuse readers without additional context. Additionally, the use of technical terms such as 'Title IX violations' might require further explanation for readers unfamiliar with U.S. education law.

5
Source quality

The article cites statements from the Trump administration and the University of Pennsylvania, but it lacks direct attribution to specific, named officials or documents, which affects the credibility of the sources. The use of an unnamed Trump official as a source raises questions about the reliability of the information provided. Furthermore, the story would benefit from additional sources, such as official statements from the NCAA or the Departments of Defense and Health and Human Services, to corroborate the claims about funding and policy changes.

5
Transparency

The article provides some context regarding the policy changes and the reasons behind the funding suspension, but it lacks transparency in terms of the sources of information. The reliance on an unnamed Trump official without further context about the email sent to reporters limits the transparency of the report. Additionally, the article does not sufficiently disclose the methodology behind the investigation into Title IX violations or the specific criteria used by the federal government to determine the funding suspension, which are critical for understanding the basis of the claims.

Sources

  1. https://www.politico.com/news/2025/03/19/upenn-federal-funding-transgender-athletes-00003279
  2. https://www.axios.com/2025/03/19/trump-university-of-pennslvania-federal-funding-transgender-athlete
  3. https://6abc.com/post/trump-administration-suspends-175-million-federal-funding-university-pennsylvania-transgender-swimmer/16051559/
  4. https://www.espn.com/college-sports/story/_/id/44317729/trump-administration-suspends-175m-penn-trans-swimmer
  5. https://www.cbsnews.com/philadelphia/news/trump-university-of-pennsylvania-funding-cuts-transgender-athletes-ncaa/