What’s to become of closed Tacoma paper mill? First, a long, complex cleanup

The former WestRock Tacoma Mill, closed in August 2023, is navigating a complex path of demolition and cleanup before it can be put on the market for sale. The site, owned by an LLC affiliated with Smurfit Westrock, faces significant challenges, including the removal of asbestos-treated structures and deteriorating storage bins. The decommissioning efforts are part of a broader restructuring following WestRock's merger with Smurfit Kappa. A demolition permit was filed in March 2024, and work is underway to safely dismantle unstable structures with high-risk materials. These efforts are crucial for preparing the nearly 60-acre site for future sale, with safety precautions heavily emphasized due to the hazardous conditions.
The significance of this story extends beyond the immediate decommissioning and sale of the mill. The site's history of contamination and its role in Tacoma's industrial landscape underscore the broader environmental challenges it faces. The cleanup process is governed by the Model Toxics Control Act, with the Washington State Department of Ecology negotiating with potentially liable parties to draft a cleanup action plan. This process, expected to take years, highlights the ongoing tension between economic development and environmental conservation. Community organizations and environmental watchdogs are closely monitoring the situation to ensure that future developments prioritize sustainability and address historical contamination.
RATING
The article provides a detailed and accurate account of the closure and cleanup of the Tacoma paper mill, supported by credible sources and thorough reporting. It effectively highlights the environmental and economic challenges associated with the site's decommissioning and potential redevelopment. However, the technical focus and limited representation of human perspectives may reduce its accessibility and engagement for a broader audience. Enhancing transparency about source biases and simplifying technical language could further improve the article's clarity and impact. Overall, the article is a valuable resource for readers interested in environmental issues and industrial site redevelopment, though it could benefit from a more balanced presentation of perspectives and increased engagement with the human impact of the mill's closure.
RATING DETAILS
The article provides a detailed account of the closure and decommissioning of the Tacoma paper mill, aligning with available information about the site's ownership, environmental concerns, and cleanup processes. The factual claims about the mill's closure in August 2023 and the ongoing decommissioning efforts are consistent with industry reports. However, some details, such as the specifics of the asbestos removal process and the timeline for cleanup, would benefit from additional verification through independent sources or official documents. The article's references to historical environmental incidents and current cleanup negotiations are well-documented, but the complexity of the legal and environmental processes involved suggests a need for cautious interpretation.
The article presents a comprehensive view of the situation, incorporating perspectives from company representatives, environmental agencies, and local community groups. It highlights the economic and environmental challenges associated with the mill's closure and potential redevelopment. However, there is a slight imbalance in favoring the technical and procedural aspects of the cleanup over the human impact, such as job losses and community concerns. Including more voices from affected employees or local residents could provide a more balanced perspective.
The article is well-structured and logically organized, with clear headings and subheadings that guide the reader through the complex issues surrounding the mill's closure and cleanup. The language is precise and technical, appropriate for the subject matter, but may be challenging for readers unfamiliar with environmental or industrial terminology. Simplifying some of the technical details or providing explanations for specialized terms could improve accessibility for a broader audience.
The article cites credible sources, including company officials, environmental agencies, and local community organizations. The use of direct quotes from individuals involved in the cleanup process adds to the reliability of the information presented. However, the article could benefit from a wider range of sources, such as independent environmental experts or legal analysts, to provide additional context and analysis of the situation.
The article is transparent about its sources, frequently quoting named individuals and organizations involved in the mill's closure and cleanup process. It provides detailed descriptions of the ongoing demolition and environmental remediation efforts. However, there is limited discussion of the potential conflicts of interest or biases of the sources cited, which could affect the impartiality of the reporting. Greater transparency about the methodology used to gather information and any potential limitations would enhance the article's credibility.
Sources
- https://ir.westrock.com/press-releases/press-release-details/2023/WestRock-Announces-Plans-to-Close-Tacoma-Wash.-Paper-Mill/default.aspx
- https://www.nwpb.org/2023/08/25/westrock-paper-mill-closing-in-tacoma-job-losses-utility-impacts-and-the-end-of-the-tacoma-aroma/
- https://komonews.com/news/local/westrock-company-aroma-of-tacoma-paper-mill-to-close-september-2023-employees-community-impact-high-operating-costs-kraft-pulp-capital-pierce-county-washington-state
- https://www.packagingdive.com/news/westrock-closures-seattle-washington-lexington-north-carolina/704932/
- https://www.fastmarkets.com/insights/westrock-retires-tacoma-mill-and-removes-510000-tpy-of-linerboard-kraft-bag-paper-pulp/
YOU MAY BE INTERESTED IN

Tacoma man said his mother died by suicide. Prosecutors allege he murdered her
Score 7.2
W.H. Sammis Power Plant smokestacks brought down in demolition
Score 7.6
16 new restaurants, bars and cafes to visit around Tacoma and the South Sound
Score 6.8
Tacoma, Pierce County death notices for February 2025
Score 7.0