What Giants might do at kicker in 2025 NFL Draft

New York Post - Apr 19th, 2025

Graham Gano, a seasoned kicker for the New York Giants, faces an uncertain future as his injury-plagued recent seasons cast doubt on his continued role with the team. At 37, Gano has struggled to stay on the field, participating in only eight games in 2023 and ten in 2024. Despite being under contract for two more years, his reliability is a growing concern for the Giants. Meanwhile, Ben Sauls from Pittsburgh emerges as a potential placekicker prospect, possibly signaling a shift in strategy for the team's kicking department.

The situation highlights the challenges aging athletes face in maintaining peak performance and the strategic decisions teams must make regarding player longevity versus fresh talent. Gano's predicament underscores the Giants' need to balance experience with the necessity for consistent availability, especially in critical game situations. As the team evaluates its options, Gano's history of injuries and Sauls' potential create a pivotal point in the Giants' roster planning, which could have broader implications for their success in upcoming seasons.

Nfl New York Giants Graham Gano Ben Sauls Sports Injuries Placekicker

Story submitted by Fairstory

RATING

6.0

Moderately Fair

Read with skepticism

The news story provides a largely accurate account of Graham Gano's current situation with the New York Giants, focusing on his age, injury history, and contract status. While the article is timely and clear, it lacks depth in sourcing and transparency, with no explicit citations or context for its claims. The narrow focus on Gano limits the balance of perspectives, and the absence of broader context may reduce its appeal to a wider audience. Despite these limitations, the article effectively communicates its main points to readers interested in NFL player dynamics and team strategies.

Accuracy

The story is largely accurate in its claims about Graham Gano's age, injury history, and contract status. It correctly identifies him as entering his 16th NFL season and notes his significant injuries over the past two seasons, aligning with publicly available data. However, the claim about Gano playing only 10 games in 2024 is plausible but not directly confirmed, and the mention of Ben Sauls lacks verification. Despite these minor gaps, the story maintains a high degree of factual accuracy overall.

Balance

The story primarily focuses on Graham Gano's career and prospects without delving into broader perspectives or potential alternatives for the Giants. While it mentions Ben Sauls as a prospective kicker, it doesn't explore other potential candidates or strategies the team might employ. This narrow focus limits the balance of viewpoints, presenting a somewhat one-sided narrative centered on Gano's situation.

Clarity

The article is generally clear and concise, presenting information in a straightforward manner. The language is accessible, and the structure allows for easy comprehension of the main points. However, the lack of detailed context and background information may hinder full understanding for readers unfamiliar with the subject.

Source quality

The article does not explicitly cite sources, which affects the perceived reliability of the information. Without clear attribution, it's challenging to assess the credibility and authority of the data presented. The lack of diverse sources or expert opinions further limits the depth and reliability of the coverage.

Transparency

The story lacks transparency in terms of sourcing and methodology. It does not provide context for the claims made about Gano's injuries or contract, nor does it disclose any potential conflicts of interest. The absence of clear attribution and context weakens the transparency of the article, leaving readers without a clear understanding of the basis for its assertions.