U.S. Attorney Alina Habba says she'll investigate Murphy, Platkin on cooperation with ICE

Acting U.S. Attorney for New Jersey, Alina Habba, has announced an investigation into Governor Phil Murphy and Attorney General Matthew Platkin for their lack of cooperation with federal immigration authorities, specifically U.S. Immigration and Customs Enforcement (ICE). Habba's statements on Fox News, where she appeared on Sean Hannity's show, indicate that the probe aims to address New Jersey's non-participation in federal immigration enforcement actions. This move is described by Habba as a non-political effort to enforce federal law and remove criminals from the country. Governor Murphy and AG Platkin are scrutinized for their adherence to New Jersey's Immigrant Trust Directive, which limits state and local police participation in federal immigration enforcement.
In response, Attorney General Platkin emphasized that the Immigrant Trust Directive is settled law, upheld by judges appointed by former President Trump, and criticized Habba for politicizing her role. Platkin stated his focus remains on maintaining public safety and expressed frustration over Habba's unwillingness to engage in dialogue. Habba, appointed by Trump and previously his personal attorney, is under scrutiny for potentially using her position to further political agendas. The investigation highlights ongoing tensions between state and federal authorities regarding immigration enforcement, with broader implications on state sovereignty and federal mandates.
RATING
The article provides a timely and relevant account of the investigation announced by Acting U.S. Attorney Alina Habba into New Jersey's top Democrats. It effectively captures the tension between state and federal authorities over immigration enforcement, a topic of significant public interest. The story is clear and well-structured, with direct quotes from key figures, but it lacks depth in exploring the legal and political nuances of the situation. The balance of perspectives could be improved by including more expert analysis or additional viewpoints. Overall, the article raises awareness of an important issue but could benefit from further exploration of the broader context and implications.
RATING DETAILS
The news story is largely accurate in presenting the main facts about the investigation announced by Acting U.S. Attorney Alina Habba into Governor Phil Murphy and Attorney General Matthew Platkin. The article correctly identifies the basis of the investigation as New Jersey's Immigrant Trust Directive, which limits cooperation with federal immigration authorities. However, the article could benefit from more precise details about the legal implications and potential outcomes of such an investigation. The story accurately quotes Habba and provides context about her background and previous roles, aligning with known facts. Areas needing verification include the legal grounds for the investigation and whether Habba's actions are politically motivated, as suggested by Platkin's response.
The article provides a reasonable balance of perspectives by including statements from both Alina Habba and Matthew Platkin. However, it leans slightly towards presenting Habba's viewpoint more prominently, possibly due to the dramatic nature of her statements on a national news platform. While Platkin's response offers a counterpoint, the article could improve balance by including more context from neutral legal experts or representatives from federal immigration agencies to provide a broader range of perspectives. The omission of such voices might lead readers to perceive a bias towards the federal perspective over the state's position.
The article is generally clear and well-structured, making it easy for readers to follow the main events and understand the positions of the involved parties. The language is straightforward, and the quotes are integrated effectively into the narrative. The article successfully conveys the tension between state and federal authorities without resorting to overly technical language or jargon. However, the inclusion of more background information on the Immigrant Trust Directive and its implications could further enhance reader comprehension.
The primary sources in the article are credible, including direct quotes from Alina Habba and Matthew Platkin, both of whom are key figures in the story. The article also references Habba's appearance on a well-known news program, which adds to the story's credibility. However, the reliance on statements made during a television appearance could be supplemented with additional sources, such as legal experts or official documents, to enhance the depth and reliability of the reporting. The article does not cite any external documents or data that could further substantiate the claims made by the involved parties.
The article provides clear quotes and context for the statements made by Alina Habba and Matthew Platkin, but it lacks depth in explaining the broader legal and political context of the Immigrant Trust Directive. While it mentions that the directive has been upheld by judges appointed by President Trump, it does not delve into the specifics of these rulings or how they might affect the investigation. The article could improve transparency by explaining the legal framework surrounding federal and state roles in immigration enforcement and any potential conflicts of interest, such as Habba's previous roles related to Trump.
Sources
- https://www.salon.com/2025/04/11/i-will-come-after-them-hard-alina-habba-investigating-nj-governor-for-snubbing-ice/
- https://www.latimes.com/world-nation/story/2025-04-11/us-attorney-habba-investigating-new-jersey-governor-over-immigration-enforcement-policy
- https://www.thedailybeast.com/alina-habba-launches-investigation-into-democratic-governor-warning-for-everybody/
- https://newjerseyglobe.com/immigration/u-s-attorney-announces-investigation-in-murphy-platkin-over-immigration-enforcement/
- https://www.politico.com/news/2025/04/11/alina-habba-new-jersey-immigration-enforcement-00286158
YOU MAY BE INTERESTED IN

U.S. Atty. Habba investigating New Jersey governor over immigration enforcement policy
Score 6.2
Government lawyer: ICE is reversing termination of legal status for international students around US
Score 7.6
Trump backs down in legal fight over canceling international students’ status records
Score 7.6
Trump-appointed judge orders return of second alleged gang banger deported to El Salvador
Score 6.8