Trump signs order shifting US back toward plastic straws

BBC - Feb 11th, 2025
Open on BBC

US President Donald Trump has signed an executive order reversing a measure by former President Joe Biden to end government purchases of plastic straws, cutlery, and packaging. This decision halts Biden's initiative aimed at addressing plastic pollution, described by Biden as a 'crisis'. Trump criticized paper straws for their functionality, stating they 'disgustingly' dissolve and break easily. The executive order takes effect immediately, marking a significant policy shift back to plastic usage in government operations.

The reversal of Biden's policy has broader implications for environmental efforts against plastic waste. Biden's administration had planned to phase out single-use plastics by 2027, with a complete ban in federal operations by 2035. Trump's stance highlights the ongoing debate about the environmental impact of plastic versus paper alternatives, with paper straws also facing scrutiny for containing 'forever chemicals' like PFAS. The issue remains contentious, as some US states have independently imposed restrictions on plastic straw usage. The story underscores the complexity of balancing consumer preferences, environmental health, and economic interests in policymaking.

Story submitted by Fairstory

RATING

5.0
Moderately Fair
Read with skepticism

The article presents a timely and relevant topic by focusing on the debate over plastic versus paper straws and the differing policies of Donald Trump and Joe Biden. It effectively engages readers with direct quotes and clear language, making it accessible to a general audience. However, the article's accuracy and balance are limited by a lack of verifiable details, diverse perspectives, and source citations. While it addresses a significant public interest issue, the potential impact is constrained by these shortcomings. To enhance its quality, the article would benefit from greater transparency, inclusion of expert opinions, and more comprehensive coverage of the environmental implications. Overall, the article provides a starting point for discussion but requires further depth and evidence to fully inform readers about the complexities of the issue.

RATING DETAILS

6
Accuracy

The article presents several factual claims that align with known events, such as Trump's criticism of paper straws and the sale of branded plastic straws during his 2020 campaign. However, the article's accuracy is somewhat undermined by the lack of verifiable details regarding the executive orders mentioned. For instance, while it states that Trump signed an executive order reversing Biden's policy, it does not provide specific information about the order's content or the exact measures it reverses. Similarly, the article claims that Biden had ordered a gradual end to government purchases of plastic items but lacks precise documentation or citation for these claims. The mention of disputed statistics, such as the number of straws used annually in the US, further highlights the need for verification. The article would benefit from citing sources or providing more concrete evidence to support its claims.

5
Balance

The article primarily presents the perspectives of Donald Trump and, to a lesser extent, Joe Biden, regarding the use of plastic versus paper straws. It highlights Trump's criticisms and actions while briefly mentioning Biden's environmental efforts. However, it lacks a balanced representation of viewpoints, particularly those of environmental groups or experts who could provide context on the implications of plastic pollution and the benefits of alternatives. The article could be perceived as biased towards Trump's perspective, given the emphasis on his quotes and opinions without counterbalancing them with other voices or data supporting the environmental rationale for reducing plastic use.

7
Clarity

The article is generally clear and straightforward in its language and structure. It effectively communicates the main points regarding Trump's executive order and his criticism of paper straws. The use of direct quotes from Trump helps convey his perspective clearly. However, the article could improve clarity by providing more context or background information on the broader environmental debate surrounding plastic use. Additionally, explaining the significance of the executive orders and their potential impact would help readers better understand the issue's complexity.

4
Source quality

The article does not cite any specific sources or experts, which weakens its credibility. It relies heavily on statements attributed to Trump and Biden without providing evidence or references to official documents, such as the executive orders mentioned. The lack of diverse and authoritative sources makes it difficult to assess the reliability of the information presented. Including expert opinions or data from reputable organizations would enhance the article's source quality and provide a more comprehensive understanding of the issue.

3
Transparency

The article lacks transparency in several areas, particularly concerning the sources of its information and the basis for its claims. It does not disclose the methodology for obtaining the statistics mentioned, such as the number of straws used annually or the financial details of Trump's campaign sales. Additionally, the article does not reveal any potential conflicts of interest or biases that might affect its impartiality. Greater transparency in these areas would enhance the reader's ability to evaluate the article's credibility and understand the context of the information presented.

Sources

  1. https://www.opb.org/article/2025/02/10/back-to-plastic-trump-pushes-for-plastic-straws-as-he-declares-paper-ones-dont-work/
  2. https://www.the-independent.com/politics/trump-straws-plastic-paper-b2694325.html
  3. https://www.washingtonexaminer.com/news/white-house/3316164/trump-signs-plastic-straw-executive-order-ends-paper/
  4. https://www.the-independent.com/news/donald-trump-joe-biden-washington-oceana-president-b2695755.html
  5. https://www.nbcphiladelphia.com/news/national-international/trump-plastic-straws/4105733/