'This town will die:' US exclave oddity at the border struggles with Trump's tariff war with Canada

Apnews - Mar 24th, 2025

Point Roberts, a unique U.S. exclave in Washington, is grappling with the repercussions of President Donald Trump's ongoing tariff war with Canada. This geopolitical tension is severely impacting the local economy, with the town's dependency on Canadian goods and services being challenged. Businesses are suffering from a decline in Canadian visitors, which has been exacerbated by unpredictable tariff changes. Local residents, many of whom did not support Trump, are facing uncertainty and financial strain, with some businesses on the brink of closure. Residents like Tamra Hansen and Hugh Wilson express their worries over the economic instability and the potential for more drastic measures, such as Canada cutting off utilities.

The situation in Point Roberts highlights the intricate interdependencies between the U.S. and Canada, particularly in border communities. The town's reliance on Canadian resources and visitors underscores the broader implications of international trade disputes on local economies. Efforts are being made by local leaders to seek intervention from higher authorities, but challenges remain in navigating diplomatic tensions at the international level. The fear of escalating confrontations could lead to further economic and social disruptions, emphasizing the need for diplomatic resolutions to protect such vulnerable communities.

Donald Trump Us Canada Relations Cross Border Trade Washington State Tariff War Point Roberts Local Economy Canadian Utilities

Story submitted by Fairstory

RATING

6.2

Moderately Fair

Read with skepticism

The article provides a compelling narrative about the economic struggles faced by Point Roberts due to tariffs, effectively highlighting the human impact of international trade policies. It is timely and relevant, addressing ongoing issues in U.S.-Canada relations. However, the article could benefit from more balanced reporting by including perspectives from Canadian officials and businesses. The reliance on local sources provides a strong human-interest angle but limits the depth and authority of the reporting. Despite some clarity issues due to technical errors, the article is generally readable and accessible. Overall, it is a well-intentioned piece that sheds light on an important issue, though it could be strengthened by broader sourcing and greater transparency.

Accuracy

The story accurately describes Point Roberts as a U.S. exclave that is economically dependent on Canada. It correctly highlights the challenges faced by local businesses due to tariffs, aligning with known facts about the area's reliance on cross-border trade. However, the claim about utilities being potentially cut off by Canada needs further verification, as it is a significant assertion without direct evidence. The voting statistics mentioned are plausible but would benefit from citation of official election data. Overall, the article presents a generally accurate picture but includes claims that require additional verification.

Balance

The article presents the perspectives of local residents and business owners who are negatively impacted by the tariffs, providing a human angle on the economic issues. However, it lacks viewpoints from Canadian officials or businesses, which could offer a more balanced view of the situation. The narrative is somewhat skewed towards the hardships faced by the community, without exploring potential benefits or neutral impacts of the tariffs. Including a broader range of perspectives would enhance the balance of the reporting.

Clarity

The article is generally clear and well-structured, with a logical flow that guides the reader through the economic challenges faced by Point Roberts. The language is straightforward, making it accessible to a broad audience. However, the inclusion of unrelated code snippets and repeated images disrupts the narrative flow and could confuse readers. Removing these elements would improve clarity.

Source quality

The article relies heavily on interviews with local residents and business owners, which provides firsthand accounts of the economic impact. However, it lacks authoritative sources such as official statements from government officials or economic data that could substantiate the claims made. The absence of diverse sources, particularly from Canadian authorities or economic experts, limits the depth and reliability of the reporting.

Transparency

The article provides a clear narrative about the economic struggles of Point Roberts, but it lacks transparency in terms of methodology and sourcing. There is no explanation of how the information was gathered or whether any efforts were made to contact Canadian officials for comment. The article would benefit from greater disclosure of the sources and methods used to obtain the information presented.