‘The drama, the process, the Conclave with author Robert Harris’

CNN - Apr 26th, 2025

The passing of Pope Francis has set in motion a significant event within the Catholic Church: the election of a new leader by the College of Cardinals. This process, known as a conclave, will bring together cardinals from around the world to decide on the next pope, a decision that will have a profound impact on the direction of the Church in the coming years. Robert Harris, the author of "Conclave," provides insight into this process, which has inspired both his book and an Oscar-winning film.

The election of a new pope is a pivotal moment for the Catholic Church, influencing its global policies and spiritual leadership. This transition comes at a time when the Church faces numerous challenges, including declining membership in some regions and addressing modern societal issues. The conclave is not just a religious event but a significant moment with political and cultural implications, as the chosen leader will play a key role in shaping the future of one of the world's largest religious institutions.

Pope Francis Catholic Church Conclave Robert Harris Leadership Election

Story submitted by Fairstory

RATING

4.4

Moderately Fair

Read with skepticism

The story presents a significant claim about the passing of Pope Francis, which is not supported by verified information, undermining its overall accuracy and credibility. While it touches on the process of electing a new pope, it lacks depth and context, failing to engage with broader implications or diverse perspectives. The absence of authoritative sources and transparency further diminishes its reliability. Despite its potential public interest and timeliness, the story's impact and engagement are limited by its inaccuracies and lack of comprehensive coverage. Overall, the story needs to address factual inaccuracies and provide a more balanced and well-sourced account to enhance its quality.

Accuracy

The story's accuracy is questionable due to a significant error regarding the status of Pope Francis. The claim that Pope Francis has passed away is not supported by current verified information, which significantly undermines the story's factual reliability. The process of cardinals electing a new pope following a pope's death or resignation is accurate, as this is the established procedure within the Catholic Church. However, the claim about Robert Harris's book 'Conclave' inspiring an Oscar-winning film lacks verification, as there is no confirmation that the film won an Oscar. Overall, the story contains both accurate and inaccurate elements, with critical facts requiring further verification.

Balance

The story presents a narrow perspective focused primarily on the procedural aspects of electing a new pope and the role of Robert Harris in depicting this process. It lacks a broader discussion of the implications of a papal transition on the Catholic Church or the global community. The omission of diverse viewpoints, such as reactions from Catholic leaders or followers, limits the story's balance. Furthermore, it does not address potential controversies or differing opinions regarding the conclave process or the influence of popular media on religious perceptions.

Clarity

The language and structure of the story are generally clear, with a straightforward presentation of its main points. However, the lack of detailed information and context can lead to confusion regarding the accuracy of the claims. The story's brevity and focus on a limited number of elements may hinder comprehension for readers unfamiliar with the Catholic Church's processes or the significance of a papal transition.

Source quality

The story does not provide direct citations or references to authoritative sources, which diminishes its credibility. The mention of Robert Harris and his book 'Conclave' serves as a secondary source, but there is no direct attribution to primary sources or official statements from the Vatican regarding the pope's status. The lack of source variety and authoritative voices, such as church officials or experts in Catholicism, weakens the story's reliability and depth.

Transparency

The story lacks transparency in its reporting, as it does not disclose the basis for its claims about Pope Francis's passing. There is no explanation of the methodology used to gather information or any acknowledgment of potential conflicts of interest. The absence of context regarding the current status of Pope Francis or the Vatican's official stance on the matter leaves readers without a clear understanding of the story's foundation.