Taliban leader says 'no need' for laws from the West in Afghanistan: 'We will create our own laws'

Taliban Supreme Leader Hibatullah Akhundzada declared there is 'no need' for Western laws in Afghanistan, emphasizing the supremacy of sharia law during a sermon for Eid al-Fitr at the Eidgah Mosque in Kandahar. His remarks highlighted the Taliban's continued commitment to their interpretation of Islamic law, which has led to severe restrictions on women and girls, limiting their education and public presence. Despite international isolation, the Taliban have succeeded in forging diplomatic ties with countries like China and the UAE.
Akhundzada's statements underscore the Taliban's hardline stance since retaking Afghanistan in 2021, after the withdrawal of U.S. and NATO forces. This approach has drawn criticism from within the Taliban ranks and from the international community, as it stands in stark contrast to earlier promises of a more moderate governance. The Taliban's limited engagement with the U.S., mainly for prisoner exchanges, reflects their complicated relationship with the West. Yet, the group's lack of credible opposition allows them to maintain control, even as some members advocate for more global engagement and policy moderation.
RATING
The article effectively reports on the Taliban leader's statements regarding Western laws and sharia, providing accurate and timely information on a topic of significant public interest. The clarity and readability of the article make it accessible to a broad audience, while the focus on controversial issues such as women's rights and international relations adds to its impact and potential to provoke discussion.
However, the article could benefit from greater balance and transparency by including more diverse perspectives and providing deeper analysis of the broader implications of the Taliban's policies. The reliance on Taliban sources limits the range of viewpoints, and additional context about the historical and political background would enhance the reader's understanding.
Overall, the article succeeds in highlighting important issues related to the Taliban's governance, but it could further engage and inform readers by expanding its coverage and incorporating a wider array of sources and perspectives.
RATING DETAILS
The story accurately reports the Taliban supreme leader Hibatullah Akhundzada's statements regarding Western laws and sharia in Afghanistan. Akhundzada's comments about the irrelevance of Western laws and the emphasis on sharia are consistent with his known public positions and the Taliban's governance style since 2021. The article also correctly notes the restrictions imposed on women and girls, which align with widely reported facts about the Taliban's policies.
The mention of diplomatic relations with countries like China and the UAE is also accurate, as these countries have engaged with the Taliban despite the group's international isolation. However, the article could benefit from more precise details about the nature of these relationships.
One area needing further verification is the claim of increased engagement between the Taliban and the U.S. under President Donald Trump, as the political context and timing mentioned appear inconsistent. Overall, the article's factual claims are well-supported by existing reports and statements, though some specific engagements and internal Taliban dynamics could use additional details.
The article primarily presents the perspective of the Taliban and their leader, with limited representation of opposing viewpoints or broader context. While it mentions internal criticism within the Taliban and some members' desire for greater international engagement, these perspectives are not explored in depth.
The story could be more balanced by including perspectives from Afghan citizens, particularly women affected by the Taliban's policies, and reactions from the international community. By focusing mainly on the Taliban's statements, the article risks presenting a one-sided view that may not fully capture the complexities of the situation in Afghanistan.
Overall, while the article provides a clear picture of the Taliban's stance, it lacks a comprehensive representation of diverse perspectives, which could enhance the reader's understanding of the broader implications of the Taliban's policies.
The article is clearly written, with a logical flow and straightforward language that makes it easy for readers to follow the main points. The structure effectively highlights the key claims made by the Taliban leader and provides context for these statements.
The use of subheadings and the inclusion of related images help to break up the text and guide the reader through the story. The tone remains neutral, focusing on reporting the facts rather than providing commentary or opinion.
However, the article could improve clarity by providing more background information on the current situation in Afghanistan and the historical context of the Taliban's policies. This would help readers who may not be familiar with the topic to better understand the implications of the reported claims.
The article cites the Taliban's official spokesperson Zabihullah Mujahid and includes references to widely recognized events and policies, lending credibility to the reported claims. However, the article relies heavily on statements from Taliban officials, which may have inherent biases.
There is a lack of diverse sources or independent verification, such as input from international organizations, Afghan civil society, or experts on Afghan politics. Including such sources could enhance the article's reliability and provide a more nuanced view of the situation.
While the sources used are credible within their context, the article would benefit from a broader range of voices to support its claims and provide a more comprehensive picture of the situation in Afghanistan.
The article provides a clear account of the Taliban leader's statements and the context in which they were made, such as the Eid al-Fitr sermon. However, it lacks transparency in terms of explaining the methodology behind the reported claims, such as how the statements were verified or the selection of certain details over others.
There is little disclosure of potential conflicts of interest or biases in the sources cited, particularly since the primary source is a Taliban spokesperson. Greater transparency about the limitations of the sources and the potential for bias would improve the article's credibility.
Overall, while the article is straightforward in presenting the Taliban's perspective, it could benefit from more explicit explanations of the context and potential biases influencing the reported information.
Sources
- https://www.indiatoday.in/world/story/no-need-for-western-laws-democracy-dead-in-afghanistan-taliban-leader-glbs-2701386-2025-03-30
- https://www.sfgate.com/news/article/the-taliban-leader-says-there-is-no-need-for-20248482.php
- https://www.justice.gov/sites/default/files/olc/legacy/2009/08/24/memo-laws-taliban-detainees.pdf
- https://www.instagram.com/firstpost/p/DH2jK2WTiQ5/
- https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Afghanistan
YOU MAY BE INTERESTED IN

Afghans at risk of persecution by Taliban arrive in Germany
Score 7.8
Could polio be poised for a comeback?
Score 7.6
Inside the Taliban's surveillance network monitoring millions
Score 7.8
Wife of detained American in Afghanistan meets with Trump's national security adviser
Score 6.0