Taiwan on edge after Pope Francis's death, closely watching Vatican-China relations

Mourners globally pay respects to Pope Francis at St. Peter's Basilica, while Taiwan faces diplomatic unease as the Vatican prepares to elect a new leader. Taiwan, with fewer than 300,000 Catholics, is wary of the Vatican's growing ties with Beijing, especially after the 2018 agreement on bishop appointments. This deal, perceived as a pastoral rather than political move, is a concern for Taiwan, which the Holy See recognizes as the sole 'China.' President William Lai initially planned to attend the pope's funeral but was replaced by former Vice President Chen Chien-jen as Taiwan's envoy.
The Vatican's relationship with Beijing is complex, as it seeks greater autonomy in spiritual matters despite China's control over its Catholic community through the Chinese Patriotic Catholic Association. With a new pope's election imminent, Taiwan fears a shift in diplomatic recognition. However, experts believe the Vatican's historical patience and China's current stance on religious freedoms suggest no immediate changes. The Vatican's diplomatic ties with Taiwan remain significant as Taiwan's number of official allies dwindles to 12, with the Holy See being a symbolically important partner.
RATING
The article provides a comprehensive and timely analysis of the diplomatic dynamics between the Vatican, Taiwan, and China following Pope Francis's death. It is largely accurate, with well-supported claims and credible sources, though it could benefit from additional perspectives, particularly from Chinese officials. The story is clear and engaging, effectively conveying complex issues to a general audience. It addresses topics of significant public interest and has the potential to spark meaningful discussion about international diplomacy and religious affairs. Overall, the article is well-structured and informative, though some areas could be enhanced with more explicit transparency and diverse viewpoints.
RATING DETAILS
The story is largely accurate, with most claims verifiable through historical records and expert commentary. For example, the article correctly states that the Holy See is the only European state maintaining diplomatic relations with Taiwan, which aligns with known diplomatic facts. The figures regarding Catholic populations in Taiwan and China are consistent with demographic data. However, the claim that Taiwan’s President initially planned to attend the funeral but later sent a former Vice President requires explicit confirmation from official statements or announcements. The article's mention of Vatican-China relations and the 2018 agreement on bishop appointments is well-documented, supporting the story's accuracy.
The article provides a balanced perspective by including views from various experts, such as Thomas Tu and Dr. Chang Ching, who offer insights into the Vatican's diplomatic strategies. It also presents the concerns of Taiwan regarding Vatican-China relations, highlighting the potential geopolitical implications. However, it could benefit from more perspectives, particularly from Chinese officials or representatives, to provide a fuller picture of the diplomatic dynamics. The inclusion of criticism from within the Church, like that of Cardinal Joseph Zen, adds depth but could be balanced with more supportive views of the Vatican's approach to China.
The article is generally clear and well-structured, with a logical flow of information. It effectively outlines the key issues surrounding Vatican-Taiwan-China relations and the implications of Pope Francis's death. The language is neutral and accessible, making it easy for readers to understand the complex diplomatic dynamics. However, some sections could benefit from clearer transitions between topics, such as the shift from discussing Taiwan's diplomatic concerns to the Vatican's broader global mission.
The article cites credible sources, including experts like Thomas Tu and Dr. Chang Ching, who provide authoritative insights into the Vatican's diplomatic relations. It also references historical events, such as previous papal funerals attended by Taiwanese officials, which adds to the story's credibility. However, the story could improve by including direct quotes or statements from official Vatican or Chinese representatives to enhance the reliability of the information presented. The use of images from reputable agencies like AFP adds visual credibility to the narrative.
The article provides a fair amount of context regarding the Vatican's diplomatic relations with Taiwan and China. It explains the historical background, such as the 2018 agreement between the Vatican and China, and the diplomatic significance of Taiwan's representation at the pope's funeral. However, the methodology behind some claims, such as the estimated number of Catholics in China and Taiwan, is not fully transparent. The article could improve by detailing the sources of these demographic figures and the basis for expert opinions more explicitly.
Sources
- https://table.media/en/https/tablemedia/china/news/death-of-pope-francis-possible-diplomatic-consequences-for-taiwan-and-china/
- https://table.media/en/china/news/pope-francis-death-possible-diplomatic-consequences-for-taiwan-and-china/
- https://focustaiwan.tw/politics/202504210024
- https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=hq9WmOfjdXw
- https://www.globalbankingandfinance.com/POPE-FRANCIS-TAIWAN-07ecf6aa-3d90-4553-b0ba-7244a5233f77
YOU MAY BE INTERESTED IN

Biden relegated to back of world leaders section at pope's funeral: 'No longer part of cool kids club'
Score 6.2
Conclave ‘very, very different’ from US elections; ‘anything could happen’, according to expert
Score 6.2
Reporter's Notebook: From John Paul II to Francis, covering two historic papacies
Score 7.8
Popes who have served the Catholic Church for the past 100 years: Champions of truth, faith and love
Score 6.6