South Dakota taxpayers spent hundreds of thousands on travel tied to Kristi Noem's political rise

Apnews - Mar 29th, 2025
Open on Apnews

Former South Dakota Governor Kristi Noem's travel expenses have sparked controversy after records revealed that over $150,000 in costs tied to her political and personal travel were covered by South Dakota taxpayers. This includes numerous trips for political campaigning and personal activities that did not pertain to state business. The expenditures, unveiled following a lawsuit by The Dakota Scout, have angered many Republicans in the traditionally conservative state, with calls for transparency and accountability. Critics argue that Noem should have used campaign funds rather than state resources for her political aspirations.

The revelation comes amidst Noem's new role as Secretary of Homeland Security in the Trump administration, highlighting issues of government waste and ethical governance. The situation underscores longstanding concerns about the lack of stringent disclosure requirements in South Dakota and the broader issue of how taxpayer funds are utilized for political purposes. As Noem continues to navigate her position in the federal government, scrutiny over her past actions may affect her political future, especially in a state known for fiscal conservatism.

Story submitted by Fairstory

RATING

7.6
Fair Story
Consider it well-founded

The article provides a thorough examination of Kristi Noem's travel expenses and their implications for government transparency and accountability. It effectively uses credible sources and direct quotes to support its claims, contributing to its accuracy and reliability. The piece is timely and relevant, addressing ongoing debates about the ethical use of taxpayer funds and the responsibilities of public officials.

While the article presents a balanced view by including criticisms and defenses of Noem's actions, it could benefit from a broader range of perspectives and more detailed analysis of the legal framework governing such expenses. The clarity and readability of the article are strong, with a logical structure and neutral tone that make it accessible to a wide audience.

Overall, the article successfully engages with a controversial topic, providing valuable insights into the complexities of government spending and accountability. It has the potential to influence public opinion and spark meaningful discussions, although its impact on policy changes may be limited without further investigation or follow-up reporting.

RATING DETAILS

8
Accuracy

The article provides a detailed account of Kristi Noem's travel expenses funded by South Dakota taxpayers, citing specific figures such as the $150,000 in expenses tied to Noem's political and personal activities and over $640,000 in total travel-related costs. These figures align with reports from credible sources. However, some elements, such as the exact legality of using state funds for security on non-state business trips, require further verification. The article accurately contextualizes these expenses within Noem's broader political activities, including trips to Palm Beach and a book tour stop in New York. The mention of a lawsuit by The Dakota Scout leading to the release of travel records is also supported by evidence. Overall, the story's claims are well-supported by available data, although some details, like the necessity of security expenses, could benefit from additional context.

7
Balance

The article provides a balanced presentation of perspectives, highlighting both the criticisms of Noem's travel expenses and the justifications offered by her spokesperson. It includes quotes from Republican figures like Dennis Daugaard and Taffy Howard, who express concern over the expenses, as well as responses from Noem's team defending the necessity of security expenses. However, the article could benefit from more perspectives, particularly from neutral experts on state finance and ethics, to provide a more comprehensive view of the issue. Additionally, the article briefly mentions similar scrutiny faced by other governors but primarily focuses on Noem, which could suggest a slight imbalance in coverage.

8
Clarity

The article is well-structured and clearly communicates the key points regarding Kristi Noem's travel expenses. It follows a logical flow, beginning with the main issue of undisclosed travel expenses and moving through the details of specific trips and the reactions from various political figures. The language is straightforward and neutral, making the content accessible to readers without specialized knowledge of the topic. However, some sections, such as the legal implications of using state funds for security, could be explained in more detail to enhance reader understanding.

8
Source quality

The article relies on credible sources, including travel records released following a lawsuit and statements from key political figures like former governors and state senators. The use of direct quotes from these individuals adds to the reliability of the information presented. The Associated Press, a reputable news organization, is the primary source, which enhances the article's credibility. However, the article could improve by incorporating more diverse sources, such as legal experts or financial analysts, to provide additional insights into the legality and ethics of the expenses discussed.

7
Transparency

The article is transparent about its sources, citing travel records and statements from political figures. It explains the context of the expenses and the legal framework surrounding disclosure requirements in South Dakota. However, the article could provide more detail on the methodology used to analyze the travel records, such as how the expenses were categorized and what criteria were used to determine their relevance to state business. Additionally, while the article mentions the lawsuit that led to the release of the records, it could further explore any potential conflicts of interest that might affect the impartiality of the reporting.

Sources

  1. https://abcnews.go.com/US/wireStory/kristi-noem-refused-financed-travel-taxpayers-hook-120286230
  2. https://americanoversight.org/american-oversight-sues-south-dakota-governor-for-records-of-noems-expenses/
  3. https://www.pbs.org/newshour/politics/south-dakota-gov-kristi-noem-sued-over-release-of-travel-expense-records
  4. https://americanoversight.org/south-dakota-judge-rejects-gov-noems-efforts-to-block-transparency-in-american-oversights-public-records-lawsuit/
  5. https://www.devdiscourse.com/article/politics/3326762-taxpayer-dollars-under-fire-kristi-noems-travel-spending-sparks-controversy