Senate confirms Dr Marty Makary as Trump's FDA chief

Fox News - Mar 25th, 2025
Open on Fox News

Dr. Marty Makary, a professor at Johns Hopkins School of Medicine and former Fox News medical contributor, has been confirmed by the Senate to lead the FDA during Trump's second administration. The confirmation, finalized with a 56-44 vote, follows his appearance before the Senate Committee on Health, Education, Labor and Pensions. During his hearing, Makary faced questions regarding the FDA's vaccine advisory committee meetings, particularly those not convened by the Biden administration for COVID-19 booster approvals. Makary responded by suggesting that the Biden administration should be questioned about these decisions, highlighting a critique of their approach to vaccine authorization.

The confirmation of Makary, who has previously criticized FDA practices, signals potential shifts in the agency's leadership and decision-making processes. His appointment is significant amidst ongoing debates about vaccine approval processes and public health strategies. Makary has expressed the need for fresh leadership to foster scientific advancement and address issues like childhood obesity and early-onset Alzheimer's. His leadership could bring changes to FDA practices, emphasizing food's impact on health and potentially reshaping American healthcare priorities under the Trump administration's influence.

Story submitted by Fairstory

RATING

6.8
Fair Story
Consider it well-founded

The article provides a timely and relevant overview of Dr. Marty Makary's confirmation as FDA Commissioner, highlighting his criticisms of the Biden administration and the FDA's vaccine authorization process. The story is generally accurate and well-structured, with clear language and a logical flow that facilitates comprehension. However, its lack of balance and transparency may affect its credibility and limit its potential to foster meaningful debate or drive policy changes. While the article addresses topics of significant public interest and has the potential to influence public opinion, improvements in source diversity and the inclusion of opposing viewpoints could enhance its overall quality and impact.

RATING DETAILS

7
Accuracy

The news story accurately reports Dr. Marty Makary's confirmation as FDA Commissioner by the Senate, with a vote of 56-44. This is a verifiable fact corroborated by multiple sources. The article also correctly identifies Makary's background as a Johns Hopkins School of Medicine professor and his previous role as a Fox News contributor. However, the story's claim about the Biden administration skipping key committee meetings for vaccine authorization needs more context. The article mentions a press release explaining why the FDA did not hold a meeting, which aligns with the administration's stated rationale but lacks additional corroboration from independent sources. The story accurately captures Makary's critical stance on the FDA's leadership and his views on health issues, which are consistent with his public statements. Overall, the article's factual claims are mostly accurate, but some details require further verification.

6
Balance

The article primarily focuses on Dr. Marty Makary's confirmation and his criticisms of the Biden administration, which may suggest a bias towards highlighting Makary's viewpoints. While it provides a platform for Makary's criticisms, it lacks counterarguments or responses from the Biden administration or other experts, which would provide a more balanced perspective. The story briefly mentions a press release explaining the administration's rationale for not convening a committee meeting, but it does not delve into opposing views or provide a comprehensive discussion of the broader implications. This lack of balance could lead readers to perceive the article as favoring Makary's perspective without adequately representing other viewpoints.

8
Clarity

The article is generally clear and well-structured, with a logical flow that guides readers through the key events of Dr. Marty Makary's confirmation. The language is straightforward, and the tone is neutral, making the information accessible to a general audience. However, some sections could benefit from additional context or explanations, particularly regarding the implications of the Biden administration's decision not to convene a committee meeting. Overall, the article effectively communicates the main points, but minor improvements in clarity could enhance readers' understanding of the complex issues involved.

7
Source quality

The article cites credible sources, including C-SPAN, Reuters, and Fox News, which are reputable news organizations. These sources provide a solid foundation for the story's claims, particularly regarding Makary's confirmation and his statements during the Senate hearing. However, the article could benefit from additional sources, such as statements from the FDA, the Biden administration, or independent experts, to enhance its credibility and provide a more comprehensive view of the issues discussed. The reliance on a limited number of sources may affect the story's impartiality, as it predominantly reflects the perspectives of those directly involved in the confirmation process.

6
Transparency

The article provides some context for Dr. Marty Makary's confirmation and his criticisms of the FDA, but it lacks transparency in certain areas. For example, it does not clearly disclose the methodology or criteria used to evaluate Makary's qualifications for the FDA role. Additionally, while the article mentions a press release explaining the Biden administration's decision not to hold a committee meeting, it does not provide direct links or detailed excerpts from the release. This lack of transparency may hinder readers' ability to fully understand the basis for the claims made in the story and the potential impact of Makary's confirmation on the FDA's future policies.

Sources

  1. https://www.foxnews.com/politics/trumps-fda-nominee-advances-full-senate-vote
  2. https://www.foxnews.com/politics/trump-picks-dr-marty-makary-food-drug-administration-commissioner
  3. https://www.help.senate.gov/rep/newsroom/press/chair-cassidy-on-senate-vote-to-confirm-martin-makary-as-fda-commissioner
  4. https://www.aabb.org/news-resources/news/article/2024/11/26/trump-announces-picks-for-top-health-positions
  5. https://www.washingtonexaminer.com/news/senate/3358975/senate-confirms-jay-bhattacharya-marty-makary-nih-cdc/