Right starts to sound like the Left on tariffs: That's not America first

Fox News contributor Mary Katharine Ham and Hoover Institution senior fellow Victor Davis Hanson discuss the implications of President Donald Trump's decision to pause tariffs and leverage against China. The debate highlights concerns over the impact on small businesses, which are still recovering from the COVID-19 pandemic's restrictions. Trump supporters are criticized for adopting strategies similar to those they previously opposed, risking principles of freedom and capitalism.
The story underscores the complexity of managing economic policies amid fiscal challenges left by the Biden administration. With U.S. debt and deficit ratios at alarming levels, the Trump administration faces limited options to stimulate growth. The discourse questions whether tariffs can effectively address these issues without harming the very principles of freedom and capitalism that small businesses rely on. The potential fallout includes the risk of foreign companies capitalizing on struggling American businesses, which contradicts the 'America First' mantra.
RATING
The article presents a critical perspective on economic policies, particularly tariffs, from a conservative viewpoint. It effectively engages with topics of public interest, such as the impact of COVID-19 measures and international trade on small businesses. However, its accuracy is undermined by a lack of detailed evidence and reliance on broad assertions without sufficient factual support.
The article's balance is skewed due to its omission of alternative perspectives and expert opinions, which could provide a more comprehensive understanding of the issues discussed. Source quality is also a concern, as the article lacks attribution to credible sources that could substantiate its claims.
While the article's language and structure are clear, its potential to provoke meaningful debate is limited by its lack of transparency and evidence. Overall, the article highlights important economic debates but falls short in providing a balanced, well-supported analysis.
RATING DETAILS
The story makes several specific claims regarding the economic and political landscape during and after the COVID-19 pandemic, as well as the effects of tariffs imposed by the Trump administration. For example, it states that the Biden administration left a 'giant fiscal mess' with a debt/GDP ratio over 120% and a deficit/GDP ratio in the 6-7% range. These figures require verification against official economic data to ensure their accuracy.
The article also claims that the global system exploited the U.S. on trade and defense, suggesting that this 'free ride' is over. This is a broad assertion that lacks specific evidence or examples, making it difficult to verify without further context or data.
Similarly, the article's assertion that tariffs may harm small businesses with international supply chains is plausible but needs specific examples or data to substantiate the claim. Overall, while the article presents a coherent narrative, many of its key claims lack the necessary factual support and specificity, leading to a middling accuracy score.
The article predominantly presents a conservative perspective, critiquing both the left's response to the COVID-19 pandemic and the right's current stance on tariffs. It suggests that both sides have moved away from principles of freedom and capitalism. However, the article does not provide a balanced view by including perspectives from those who support the measures it criticizes.
There is a lack of representation from economic experts or policymakers who might offer alternative viewpoints on the effectiveness of tariffs or the fiscal policies of the Biden administration. This omission skews the narrative towards a particular ideological stance without adequately exploring counterarguments or the rationale behind the criticized policies.
The article is generally clear in its language and structure, making its main arguments understandable. It uses straightforward language to critique the policies of both political sides, although the tone is somewhat biased, which might affect the neutrality perceived by the readers.
The logical flow of the article is mostly coherent, as it transitions from discussing the impact of COVID-19 policies to the implications of tariffs. However, the lack of detailed evidence or data to support its claims can lead to confusion about the validity of its arguments, slightly undermining its clarity.
The story lacks detailed attribution to credible sources. While it mentions public figures like President Trump and Commerce Secretary Howard Lutnick, it does not provide direct quotes, data, or references from authoritative economic or political analysts to support its claims.
The absence of diverse and reliable sources diminishes the credibility of the article. It relies heavily on opinion and broad assertions without backing them up with evidence from reputable sources, which is crucial for maintaining impartiality and credibility in news reporting.
The article does not clearly disclose the basis for many of its claims, such as the specific data sources or methodologies used to arrive at its economic assessments. For instance, the fiscal metrics attributed to the Biden administration are presented without context or supporting data.
There is little explanation of the potential conflicts of interest or biases that might influence the narrative. The lack of transparency about how conclusions were drawn or what evidence supports the claims reduces the article's overall transparency and leaves readers without a clear understanding of the article's foundation.
Sources
- https://www.whitehouse.gov/presidential-actions/2025/04/amendment-to-recipricol-tariffs-and-updated-duties-as-applied-to-low-value-imports-from-the-peoples-republic-of-china/
- https://www.foxnews.com/politics/dem-governors-revolt-against-trumps-liberation-day-tariffs
- https://www.foxnews.com/opinion/trump-risks-all-takes-world-tariffs-puts-america-first
- https://www.foxnews.com/politics/trump-vows-nobody-getting-off-hook-unfair-trade-balances-says-no-tariff-exception
- https://www.foxnews.com
YOU MAY BE INTERESTED IN

Shein and Temu raise prices in response to Trump tariffs
Score 4.8
President Trump blasts courts for getting in the way of deportation agenda
Score 6.0
What is Donald Trump's approval rating today? Latest US polls of Fox, Gallup, Rasmussen, Reuters
Score 5.4
Trump renews attacks on Powell, accelerating US market slide
Score 7.6