Philippines’ Black Nazarene procession draws hundreds of thousands of devotees | CNN

CNN - Jan 10th, 2025
Open on CNN

Hundreds of thousands of devout Filipinos participated in the annual Black Nazarene procession in Manila, marking one of the largest public displays of Catholic faith worldwide. As the life-sized statue of Jesus Christ, known as the Black Nazarene, was paraded through the streets, devotees dressed in maroon and gold sought to touch the statue, believing in its power to bless and heal. Approximately 220,000 attended the pre-procession mass, and the crowd swelled to over 94,500 as the 5.8 km journey commenced, showcasing the fervent faith deeply rooted in the Philippines, a predominantly Roman Catholic nation due to centuries of Spanish colonial influence.

The event, known as the 'traslacion,' commemorates the historical transfer of the Black Nazarene statue from the old Spanish colonial capital of Intramuros to Quiapo Church. Cardinal Jose Advincula emphasized moral guidance, urging participants to adhere to Christ's teachings, turning away from sin and vice. This cultural and religious event underscores the enduring impact of Spanish colonization on Filipino religious practices and highlights the Black Nazarene's significant role in Filipino spirituality. The procession not only reflects religious devotion but also serves as a powerful symbol of cultural identity and continuity in the Philippines.

Story submitted by Fairstory

RATING

7.0
Fair Story
Consider it well-founded

The article offers a vivid portrayal of a significant religious event in the Philippines, capturing the fervor and dedication of its participants. It excels in accuracy and clarity, providing a detailed description of the event and its cultural context. However, it lacks balance by presenting solely the perspective of the church and its followers without exploring secular or critical viewpoints. The article uses reliable sources, though more diverse citations could enhance its credibility. Transparency is moderate, as it does not delve into the methodologies behind its statistics or potential influences on its narrative. Overall, while informative and engaging, the article could benefit from a broader exploration of perspectives and more explicit source attributions.

RATING DETAILS

8
Accuracy

The article presents a factual account of the Black Nazarene procession, a major religious event in the Philippines, with details that align with known historical and cultural facts. It accurately describes the procession, the estimated number of participants, and the cultural significance of the event, supported by historical context about the Spanish colonization's impact on Filipino Catholicism. The mention of Sabino Vengco's explanation of the statue's black color adds depth and corrects a common myth, enhancing the article's factual reliability. However, the article could benefit from additional sources to substantiate the estimated attendance figures and the historical claims about the statue's origins. Overall, the article is well-researched and truthful but would be strengthened by more verifiable data and citations.

6
Balance

While the article effectively captures the devotion of the participants and the religious significance of the Black Nazarene procession, it lacks balance by failing to include a range of perspectives. The narrative focuses exclusively on the religious fervor and the church's viewpoint, particularly through the homily by Cardinal Jose Advincula, without exploring secular or critical perspectives. For example, insights from sociologists, anthropologists, or local residents not participating in the event could provide a more rounded view of the cultural and social implications of such a large-scale religious gathering. Additionally, the article does not address any potential controversies, such as the impact on public safety or economic aspects. Thus, while it presents a coherent and well-articulated account of the religious side, the lack of diverse perspectives limits its overall balance.

9
Clarity

The article is well-written, with clear and engaging language that effectively conveys the atmosphere and significance of the Black Nazarene procession. The structure is logical, beginning with a vivid depiction of the event and then providing historical context and expert commentary. The tone remains neutral and professional, avoiding emotive language that could detract from the factual nature of the report. Complex information, such as the historical background of the statue and the cultural significance of the event, is presented in an accessible manner. However, the article could improve by providing more detailed explanations of some terms, such as 'traslacion' for readers unfamiliar with the event. Overall, the article excels in clarity, offering an informative and coherent account of the procession.

7
Source quality

The article references credible sources such as the procession's organizers for attendance estimates and a respected theologian for historical context, lending weight to its claims. However, it lacks a variety of sources that could enhance its depth and credibility. The absence of direct quotes from participants or experts in Filipino culture or religion is a notable gap. Additionally, the reliance on a single theologian for debunking the myth around the statue's color, while informative, could be strengthened by referencing additional scholarly or historical sources. The article would benefit from citing more diverse and authoritative sources, such as academic studies or official records, to bolster its claims and provide a more comprehensive perspective on the event.

5
Transparency

The article provides a straightforward account of the event but lacks transparency in several aspects. It does not clearly disclose the methodologies used to estimate the number of participants, nor does it provide information about the affiliations or motivations of the procession's organizers. There is also no discussion of potential biases or conflicts of interest that might influence the narrative, such as the church's role in promoting the event or any commercial interests tied to the procession. While the article does include a historical correction from theologian Sabino Vengco, it does not explain how this information was verified or sourced. Greater transparency regarding the basis for its claims and any potential influences on its reporting would enhance the article's credibility.