Paramount, CBS settle discrimination lawsuit over DEI policies punishing straight White males

Fox News - Apr 24th, 2025
Open on Fox News

CBS has settled a lawsuit filed by former 'SEAL Team' writer Brian Beneker, who alleged racial discrimination against straight, White males within the network. The settlement comes as CBS and its parent company, Paramount Global, face a significant legal battle with President Donald Trump, who is suing the network for $20 billion. Trump accuses CBS of election interference related to the editing of a '60 Minutes' interview with Vice President Kamala Harris ahead of the 2024 election. The departure of '60 Minutes' executive producer Bill Owens has added to the turmoil at the network.

The discrimination lawsuit settlement reflects a shift in CBS's policies regarding diversity, equity, and inclusion (DEI). Previously, CBS had aimed to increase BIPOC representation in its writers' rooms, but following Trump's re-election and anti-DEI policies, Paramount Global has announced a rollback of these initiatives. This includes ending the use of diversity quotas and the collection of demographic data unless legally required. The developments highlight the ongoing tension within the entertainment industry over DEI policies and the legal and political challenges faced by major media organizations.

Story submitted by Fairstory

RATING

6.2
Moderately Fair
Read with skepticism

The article provides a timely and relevant examination of legal and diversity issues in the media industry, focusing on a discrimination lawsuit involving Paramount Global and CBS, and a high-stakes legal battle with President Trump. While the story presents verifiable claims and engages with important public interest topics, it lacks balance by not sufficiently including perspectives from CBS or Paramount. The reliance on America First Legal as a primary source limits the diversity of viewpoints, affecting the article's overall credibility. The narrative could benefit from improved structure and clarity, particularly in explaining complex legal and industry-specific terms. Despite these weaknesses, the article has the potential to influence public opinion and provoke meaningful discussion on diversity policies and media accountability.

RATING DETAILS

7
Accuracy

The story presents several factual claims that are largely verifiable, such as the settlement of a discrimination lawsuit by Paramount Global and CBS, and the involvement of America First Legal in representing the plaintiff, Brian Beneker. These claims align with available information, indicating a reasonable level of truthfulness and precision. However, some details, like the specifics of the settlement and the exact nature of the DEI policies being rolled back, require further verification. Additionally, the article's mention of a $20 billion lawsuit filed by President Trump against CBS for alleged election interference is a significant claim that needs thorough corroboration. Overall, while most facts are supported by credible sources, some areas need more evidence to confirm their accuracy.

6
Balance

The article primarily focuses on the perspective of the plaintiff, Brian Beneker, and America First Legal, which represents him. It includes their viewpoints extensively, especially regarding the rollback of DEI policies at CBS and Paramount. However, the story lacks balance by not sufficiently presenting counterarguments or perspectives from CBS or Paramount. The brief mention of reaching out to these companies for comment without their responses leaves the narrative somewhat one-sided. Including more viewpoints from the companies involved or other industry experts could provide a more balanced representation of the issues at hand.

6
Clarity

The article is generally clear in its presentation of the main events and claims. However, the narrative could be better structured to enhance comprehension. The story jumps between different topics, such as the discrimination lawsuit, DEI policies, and the lawsuit from President Trump, which can confuse readers. A more logical flow and clearer separation of these topics would improve the article's readability. Additionally, some jargon related to legal and industry-specific terms might not be easily understood by a general audience, potentially hindering clarity.

7
Source quality

The article cites America First Legal as a primary source, which is a credible organization known for its legal and advocacy work. However, the reliance on a single perspective from AFL might affect the overall reliability of the reporting. The story would benefit from a wider variety of sources, including statements from CBS and Paramount, to enhance the credibility and depth of the information presented. While Fox News Digital is a reputable news outlet, the lack of multiple authoritative voices in the article limits the robustness of the source quality.

5
Transparency

The article provides some context about the lawsuit and the broader legal battles involving CBS, such as the lawsuit from President Trump. However, it lacks detailed explanations of the methodology behind the claims, such as the specific legal arguments used in the discrimination case or the criteria for rolling back DEI policies. The absence of this information makes it difficult for readers to fully understand the basis of the claims and the potential biases involved. Greater transparency in explaining the underlying factors and motivations would improve the article's clarity and impartiality.

Sources

  1. https://aflegal.org/paramount-and-cbs-end-unlawful-dei-policies-following-afl-lawsuits-afl-secures-amicable-resolution-of-brian-benekers-discrimination-claim-against-paramount-and-cbs/
  2. https://www.imdb.com/news/ni65244195/
  3. https://eloncdn.blob.core.windows.net/eu3/sites/446/2022/04/SURF-2022-Program_Final.pdf