Nancy Mace calls transgender student a transphobic slur at University of South Carolina event

U.S. Representative Nancy Mace repeated a transphobic slur during an event at the University of South Carolina, causing an uproar among students. The event, organized by the USC chapter of right-wing group Turning Point USA, saw Mace confronted by Harley Hicks, a transgender student, who asked for an apology over her language. Mace dismissed the request by repeating the slur multiple times, an interaction she later posted online while misgendering Hicks and suggesting an intent to assault her, which Hicks denied.
Mace's behavior highlights a pattern of using derogatory language against the transgender community. Her repeated use of the slur has been documented in previous incidents, including during a Capitol Hill protest and a House Oversight Committee hearing. These actions underscore growing tensions between Mace and LGBTQ+ activists, raising questions about the impact of her rhetoric on her political career and its implications for public discourse on transgender rights. The incident reflects broader societal debates around respect, language, and the rights of marginalized communities.
RATING
The article provides a timely and engaging account of a controversial incident involving U.S. Rep. Nancy Mace and her use of derogatory language toward a transgender student. It effectively highlights issues of public interest, such as the responsibilities of public officials and the impact of language on marginalized communities. However, the article's credibility and impact are somewhat limited by its lack of balance and transparency, as it predominantly presents a critical perspective without including diverse viewpoints or comprehensive sourcing. Enhancing these aspects would improve the article's ability to foster meaningful discussion and contribute to the broader conversation on these important issues. Overall, the article succeeds in drawing attention to a significant event but would benefit from a more balanced and transparent approach to reporting.
RATING DETAILS
The story claims that U.S. Rep. Nancy Mace used a dehumanizing slur for transgender people directly to a trans student at an event at the University of South Carolina. This claim is supported by multiple sources, including video evidence and eyewitness accounts. The article accurately reports the venue and the organization hosting the event, Turning Point USA, and its designation by the Southern Poverty Law Center as an extremist hate group. However, the story could benefit from additional verification of the specific language used and the context of Mace's comments during the event. Furthermore, the claim that Mace has a history of using the slur in other contexts, such as during a House Oversight Committee hearing, is supported by past reports, but the specific details of those instances would require further corroboration. Overall, while the article presents a largely accurate account, it would be strengthened by more direct evidence and context for some of the claims made.
The article presents a predominantly critical perspective on Nancy Mace's actions, focusing heavily on her use of derogatory language and the reactions of those opposing her. The story lacks a balanced representation of viewpoints, as it does not include any statements or perspectives from Mace or her supporters. This omission creates an impression of bias, as the article does not explore potential justifications or explanations from Mace's side. A more balanced approach would include Mace's perspective, or at least an acknowledgment of her stance, to provide readers with a comprehensive understanding of the situation. Additionally, the article could benefit from presenting the broader context of the event and the reactions from a wider range of attendees.
The article is generally clear and concise in its presentation of the events and claims. The language is straightforward, and the narrative follows a logical progression from the event at the University of South Carolina to Mace's past actions. However, the tone of the article is somewhat biased, as it uses charged language and descriptions that may influence readers' perceptions. For example, describing Mace's behavior as 'smugness of a child' introduces a subjective element that detracts from the article's neutrality. A more neutral tone and language would enhance the clarity and objectivity of the reporting.
The article relies on a mix of sources, including direct video evidence of the event, social media posts, and reports from other news outlets. While these sources provide a foundation for the claims made, the article would benefit from citing more authoritative sources, such as official statements from the University of South Carolina or Turning Point USA. The reliance on social media and secondary reports introduces potential issues with reliability, as these sources can be subject to bias or misinterpretation. Including more direct quotes from primary participants or official records would enhance the credibility of the reporting.
The article provides some context for the event and the actions of Nancy Mace, but it falls short in fully disclosing the basis for all claims made. While the article mentions video evidence and social media posts, it does not provide direct links or detailed descriptions of these sources, making it difficult for readers to independently verify the information. Additionally, the article does not disclose any potential conflicts of interest or biases in its reporting, which could impact the perceived impartiality of the piece. Greater transparency in the sourcing and methodology would improve the article's credibility and trustworthiness.
Sources
- https://www.dailygamecock.com/article/2025/04/usc-turning-point-usa-chapter-hosts-nancy-mace-generates-large-audience-response-news-bassett
- https://www.advocate.com/politics/nancy-mace-usc-trans-slur
- https://www.instagram.com/cnn/reel/DFuwuxcuofT/
- https://spectrumlocalnews.com/nc/triad/news/2025/02/06/nancy-mace-slur-hearing-transgender
- https://cbsaustin.com/news/nation-world/i-dont-really-care-south-carolina-rep-nancy-mace-spews-anti-trans-slur-during-house-hearing-rightsizing-government-usaid-rep-gerry-connolly-womens-restrooms-us-capitol
YOU MAY BE INTERESTED IN

Transgender Influencer Hits Back at Nancy Mace: 'Bullying Me for Being Hot'
Score 6.4
Trans baby killer filed $3.5M lawsuit against Trump for ‘transphobic’ views that led to alleged sexual assaults behind bars
Score 5.2
Senate Democrats press Hegseth for answers on Trump order to ban transgender troops
Score 7.2
Pope Francis’ death puts major choice before his church
Score 5.0