Migrant accused of killing 2-month old baby looked like loving dad in photo with tot, who was Queens’ baby New Year

Marlon Rabanales-Pretzantzin, a 20-year-old illegal migrant, has been charged with the murder of his 2-month-old daughter on Long Island. The tragic incident unfolded when Rabanales-Pretzantzin allegedly beat his daughter, Liseyda Rabanales-Barrios, to death in a violent outburst on March 7, 2025. The alleged crime starkly contrasts with earlier images of a seemingly loving father and a happy family celebrating their newborn as the first baby born in Queens in 2025. The family had received gifts such as a diaper bag and baby monitor to help them start their new life. However, the family's happiness was shattered when the father, allegedly convinced the child was not his, resorted to violence, resulting in severe injuries and the child's death. Rabanales-Pretzantzin has been held without bail following his confession to the murder.
The incident has raised significant concerns about domestic violence and the challenges facing undocumented migrants. Rabanales-Pretzantzin crossed the Mexico-El Paso border illegally in 2022 and was released by Border Patrol after being apprehended. His story highlights the complexities of immigration and the potential consequences of inadequate support systems for migrant families. The case has garnered widespread attention, drawing focus to the broader issues of mental health, family dynamics, and the social services available to immigrant communities in the United States. As the legal proceedings unfold, the community grapples with the implications of this tragic event and what it means for migrant families living in similar circumstances.
RATING
The article covers a highly sensitive and controversial topic involving a serious crime and immigration issues. While it is timely and addresses matters of public interest, its accuracy is undermined by inconsistencies and a lack of authoritative sources. The narrative is clear but leans towards sensationalism, particularly in its depiction of the alleged crime. The story could benefit from a more balanced presentation by including perspectives from the suspect's legal representatives and exploring broader societal implications. Overall, the article engages with important themes but requires more thorough reporting and verification to enhance its reliability and impact.
RATING DETAILS
The story presents several factual claims that require verification, such as the immigration status of Marlon Rabanales-Pretzantzin and the details surrounding the alleged crime. The article states that he entered the U.S. illegally through the Mexico-El Paso border and was released by Border Patrol, which aligns with typical procedures but lacks specific source attribution for these claims. Additionally, the story mentions the baby's birth details and names, which are inconsistent within the article itself, as it refers to both Liseyda Rabanales-Barrios and Jimena Sulemia. These discrepancies highlight the need for confirmation from official records or reliable sources. Furthermore, the description of the alleged crime is detailed, yet it is based on a criminal complaint, which needs corroboration through legal documents or police reports. While the article includes quotes from a local deli owner, these are anecdotal and do not confirm the claims about Rabanales-Pretzantzin’s character or actions.
The article primarily focuses on the alleged crime and the background of Marlon Rabanales-Pretzantzin, presenting a narrative that could be perceived as biased against him due to his immigration status. It emphasizes his illegal entry into the U.S. and his subsequent actions without providing a broader context or perspective from his family or legal representatives. The story could benefit from including additional viewpoints, such as statements from the defense attorney or community members who might offer a different perspective on Rabanales-Pretzantzin's character and circumstances. By focusing heavily on the crime and the suspect's immigration status, the article may inadvertently reinforce stereotypes without exploring underlying issues or alternative narratives.
The article is generally clear in its language and structure, providing a straightforward narrative of the events and background of the individuals involved. However, the inconsistency in the baby's name and the lack of clarity about the timeline of events can confuse readers. The article could benefit from a more logical flow that distinguishes between verified facts and allegations. The tone of the article is neutral in terms of language but leans towards sensationalism in its description of the alleged crime. Improving clarity would involve ensuring consistency in details and providing a more structured presentation of the information.
The article relies on a mix of unnamed sources, such as neighbors and a deli owner, which raises questions about the reliability and credibility of the information presented. These sources provide anecdotal evidence rather than verified facts. The story does not reference any official statements from law enforcement or legal documents, which would enhance the credibility of the claims made. The lack of authoritative sources and reliance on hearsay weakens the overall quality of the reporting, as readers cannot easily assess the trustworthiness of the information provided. The absence of direct quotes from police reports or court documents further diminishes the article's source quality.
The article lacks transparency in its reporting, as it does not clearly disclose the sources of its information or the methodology used to gather it. There is no explanation of how the reporters verified the details of the alleged crime or the suspect's immigration status. Additionally, the article does not address potential conflicts of interest or biases that may affect the reporting. Without clear attribution or explanation of the information's origin, readers are left to question the basis of the claims made. The story could improve transparency by providing more context and clarity about the sources and methods used to obtain the information.
Sources
- https://www.nbcnewyork.com/long-island/long-island-dad-murder-beating-2-month-old-daughter-death/6186551/
- https://acecomments.mu.nu/?post=390325%3Futm_source%3Dpolitipage
- https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=EdS4Y41rOaQ
- http://acecomments.mu.nu/?post=387226%3Futm_source%3Dakdart
- https://www.foxnews.com/us/alleged-illegal-migrant-dad-accused-beating-baby-death-he-did-not-respect-want-baby
YOU MAY BE INTERESTED IN

Police Identify Woman Burned To Death On NYC Subway
Score 6.4
Ex-New Mexico judge, wife tried to hide evidence of illegal alien gangbanger, DOJ prosecutors say
Score 7.2
George Santos accused of weeping ‘crocodile tears’ by Navy vet who claimed ex-pol stole thousands from his dying dog
Score 5.8
Tacoma man said his mother died by suicide. Prosecutors allege he murdered her
Score 7.2