Man pleads guilty in drive-by shooting that killed Washington County grandmother

Yahoo! News - May 16th, 2025

Juan Worthey, 20, has pleaded guilty to third-degree murder in connection with a drive-by shooting in Washington that resulted in the death of Kristin Barfield. The plea came on the same day jury selection was to begin for his trial. The shooting incident, which occurred in 2022, also involved Brandon Allen, 30, and Tyriq Moss. Barfield was killed as she sat on her front porch, with the shots directed at her son. While Allen, the driver, was acquitted of homicide but found guilty of criminal attempted homicide and conspiracy, Moss, who was 15 at the time, testified against his co-defendants in exchange for having his charges dropped. Worthey now faces a potential sentence of up to 40 years, with sentencing scheduled for July.

The case highlights the severe consequences of gun violence and the complexities of legal proceedings involving multiple defendants with different roles in the crime. The plea deal and subsequent testimonies underscore prosecutorial strategies in securing convictions and the challenges of juvenile involvement in violent crimes. The incident has brought attention to community safety concerns and the need for addressing gun violence, particularly in areas where such events have tragically claimed innocent lives. As Worthey awaits sentencing, the community continues to grapple with the aftermath of the violence and its impact on victims' families.

Gun Violence Washington Legal Proceedings Drive By Shooting Juan Worthey Kristin Barfield Brandon Allen Tyriq Moss Third Degree Murder

Story submitted by Fairstory

RATING

7.2

Fair Story

Consider it well-founded

The article provides a well-researched and accurate account of a legal case involving a drive-by shooting, supported by reliable sources. It is timely and addresses issues of public interest, such as community safety and legal accountability. While the story is clear and accessible, it could benefit from greater transparency in source attribution and a more balanced inclusion of perspectives to enhance its depth and engagement potential. The coverage is primarily factual, with limited exploration of controversial aspects, which might restrict its impact and ability to provoke broader societal discussions.

Accuracy

The story demonstrates a high degree of factual accuracy, with most claims consistent with available information. The plea of Juan Worthey to third-degree murder, the involvement of Brandon Allen and Tyriq Moss, and the details surrounding the drive-by shooting are all accurately reported. However, the story could benefit from additional verification regarding the precise legal outcomes for each individual involved, particularly the terms of Moss's prosecutorial deal and the specific charges Worthey pleaded guilty to. Overall, the article presents a truthful and precise account, supported by reliable sources.

Balance

The article maintains a fairly balanced perspective, focusing on the legal proceedings and outcomes for the individuals involved in the shooting. It provides information about each defendant's role and the judicial decisions made. However, the story could include more perspectives, such as statements from the victim's family or community reactions, to offer a fuller picture of the incident's impact. The current focus on the legal aspects might omit some emotional or societal dimensions that are equally important.

Clarity

The article is generally clear and concise, with a straightforward presentation of facts. The language is accessible, and the sequence of events is logically structured. However, the narrative could be improved by providing more context about the legal terms used, such as 'third-degree murder' and 'criminal attempted homicide,' to aid reader comprehension. Additionally, brief background information on the victim and the defendants could enhance understanding of the story's significance.

Source quality

The article cites reputable sources, such as WJPA and WPXI, which are known for their local news coverage. These sources lend credibility to the report, given their proximity to the events and their track record in news reporting. The use of partner sources suggests a level of verification and collaboration that enhances reliability. However, the article would benefit from direct quotes or statements from law enforcement or legal officials to further bolster its authority.

Transparency

While the article provides clear information about the main events and individuals involved, it lacks some transparency in terms of the sources of its information. The reference to 'our partner WJPA' is vague without specific attribution to individuals or reports. Additionally, there is no explanation of how the information was gathered, which could help readers understand the basis for the claims made. Greater transparency in source attribution and methodology would improve reader trust.