Jon Gruden recalls hilarious Peyton Manning jab after ill-advised play call

Fox News - Apr 16th, 2025
Open on Fox News

During the latest episode of Barstool Sports' 'Gruden's QB Class,' former NFL head coach Jon Gruden recounted a memorable encounter with Hall of Fame quarterback Peyton Manning. Gruden, without specifying the team he was coaching at the time, described how his all-out blitz strategy against Manning and the Indianapolis Colts backfired. Manning, renowned for his pre-snap reads, quickly adjusted, resulting in a touchdown. Gruden humorously recalled Manning taunting him on the sidelines, highlighting the quarterback's legendary game awareness.

The story not only sheds light on Manning's exceptional skills but also connects to the aspirations of Seth Henigan, a 2025 NFL Draft prospect featured in the episode. Henigan, a successful quarterback at Memphis, aims to emulate Manning's career, though he acknowledges the work needed to reach the NFL level. This anecdote underscores the challenges and learning experiences young quarterbacks face as they transition to the professional stage, emphasizing the significance of strategic thinking and adaptability in football.

Story submitted by Fairstory

RATING

5.6
Moderately Fair
Read with skepticism

The article provides an entertaining recount of an anecdote involving Jon Gruden and Peyton Manning, appealing to sports enthusiasts. While it effectively captures Gruden's storytelling, the story's accuracy is somewhat limited by its reliance on a single perspective without independent verification. The narrative is clear and engaging, but the lack of broader context or diverse viewpoints results in limited balance and impact. The story's potential to engage a wider audience is constrained by its focus on a historical anecdote and speculative player prospects, reducing its timeliness and public interest appeal.

RATING DETAILS

6
Accuracy

The story is generally accurate in its recounting of Jon Gruden's anecdote about Peyton Manning, but there are elements that require further verification. The claim that Manning said, "Are you out of your f---ing mind?" is based solely on Gruden's recollection and lacks independent confirmation. The article accurately cites Manning's career achievements, such as his Super Bowl wins and passing yards, which align with known facts. However, the specific game or date of the incident is not provided, leaving a gap in factual precision.

5
Balance

The article primarily presents Jon Gruden's perspective, with little input from other sources or viewpoints. It focuses on Gruden's storytelling and Manning's prowess without exploring other angles, such as Manning's perspective on the incident. This limited viewpoint could lead to an imbalanced representation of the story, as it does not consider the broader context or other interpretations of the event.

7
Clarity

The article is clearly written, with a straightforward narrative that is easy to follow. The language is accessible, and the structure logically presents the anecdote and related information. However, the transition between the anecdote and the details about Seth Henigan's prospects could be smoother to maintain a consistent narrative flow.

4
Source quality

The information is sourced from Jon Gruden's own account, which is subjective and anecdotal. There is no corroboration from other sources or witnesses, which diminishes the reliability of the story. While the article references Gruden's and Manning's public profiles, it lacks diverse sources that could enhance the credibility and depth of the reporting.

6
Transparency

The article makes clear that the story is a recounting by Jon Gruden, which provides some transparency about the origin of the claims. However, it does not disclose any efforts to verify the anecdote or seek comments from other parties involved. This lack of methodological transparency limits the reader's ability to assess the impartiality and thoroughness of the reporting.

Sources

  1. https://www.fanrunradio.com/sports/peyton-manning-asks-jon-gruden-are-you-out-of-your-fcking-mind
  2. https://larrybrownsports.com/football/peyton-manning-trash-talk-jon-gruden/692461
  3. https://www.yardbarker.com/nfl/articles/peyton_manning_had_incredible_trash_talk_for_jon_gruden/s1_127_42057245
  4. https://newstral.com/en/article/en/1265686603/jon-gruden-recalls-hilarious-peyton-manning-jab-after-ill-advised-play-call
  5. http://www.coachwyatt.com/news.html?kee..