ICE facility Democrats 'stormed' holds child rapists, murderers: officials

Fox News - May 10th, 2025
Open on Fox News

Democratic lawmakers and protesters stormed the Delaney Hall Detention Center in Newark, New Jersey, advocating for detainees labeled by DHS as dangerous criminals. The incident, which included members of Congress, resulted in a confrontation at the security gate as demonstrators attempted to stop a bus transporting detainees. Homeland Security Assistant Secretary Tricia McLaughlin condemned the actions, highlighting the criminal backgrounds of the detainees involved. Among those detained were individuals with ties to MS-13 and other serious charges, including murder and drug trafficking.

The event has sparked a heated debate over the appropriate conduct of lawmakers and the treatment of detainees in immigration facilities. While Democratic Representative LaMonica McIver claimed to have been mistreated by ICE officials, DHS footage suggests otherwise, showing her pushing and elbowing security personnel. The White House criticized the lawmakers' actions as crossing the line, further intensifying political tensions. This incident underscores the ongoing national conversation about immigration policy, law enforcement, and the balance between advocacy and security.

Story submitted by Fairstory

RATING

6.4
Moderately Fair
Read with skepticism

The news story presents a timely and engaging account of an incident involving Democratic lawmakers and a detention center, but it shows potential biases by emphasizing certain perspectives over others. The article accurately reports on some aspects, such as the details of the detainees' criminal backgrounds, yet it lacks a balanced portrayal of the lawmakers' intentions and actions. The reliance on a single news outlet and government sources limits the diversity of viewpoints, affecting the story's balance and source quality. While the article is clear and readable, the use of charged language could influence readers' perceptions. Overall, the story is relevant and has the potential to provoke discussion on immigration policy and governmental oversight, but it would benefit from greater transparency and inclusion of multiple perspectives.

RATING DETAILS

6
Accuracy

The factual accuracy of the story is mixed. The article claims that Democratic lawmakers and protesters stormed the Delaney Hall Detention Center, which is supported by the Department of Homeland Security's (DHS) account. However, there are conflicting reports about whether this was an aggressive action or an oversight visit. The story provides specific details about the detainees, such as Chinchilla Caballero being an MS-13 member and Ramos Marin being wanted for murder in Brazil, which align with DHS statements. However, the characterization of the facility as holding only high-profile criminals like terrorists and gang members may not fully capture the complexity of the detainee population. The claim about Rep. LaMonica McIver being manhandled by ICE officials is contradicted by DHS footage, which shows her pushing officials, indicating potential inaccuracies in the lawmakers' accounts.

5
Balance

The article primarily presents the perspective of the Department of Homeland Security and Fox News, which may lead to a biased portrayal of the events. The story emphasizes the criminal backgrounds of the detainees and the alleged aggressive actions of the lawmakers, potentially neglecting the lawmakers' intention of conducting an oversight visit. The lack of direct quotes or statements from the lawmakers or their representatives limits the range of viewpoints, creating an imbalance in the narrative. The absence of context regarding the broader immigration policy debate and the motivations behind the lawmakers' actions further skews the presentation.

8
Clarity

The article is generally clear and concise, presenting the key facts and claims in a straightforward manner. The language is accessible, and the structure follows a logical progression from the incident to the details about the detainees. However, the use of charged language, such as 'stormed' and 'manhandled,' could influence readers' perceptions and affect the neutrality of the narrative. Overall, the article is understandable but could improve in maintaining a neutral tone throughout.

7
Source quality

The primary sources cited in the article include the Department of Homeland Security and Fox News, both of which have authority in reporting on law enforcement and political matters. However, the reliance on a single news outlet and government agency may limit the diversity of perspectives and introduce potential biases. The article does not provide information from independent or third-party sources that could corroborate or challenge the DHS's account, affecting the overall reliability of the information presented.

6
Transparency

The article provides specific details about the detainees and the incident at the detention center, but it lacks transparency in disclosing the methodology behind the claims. There is no explanation of how the information was obtained or verified, and the potential conflicts of interest, such as the political affiliations of the sources, are not addressed. The article would benefit from greater transparency in its sourcing and the inclusion of more context about the motivations and actions of all parties involved.

Sources

  1. https://abcnews.go.com/Politics/newark-mayor-arrested-ice-facility-joining-democrats-conduct/story?id=121652689
  2. https://www.wsws.org/en/articles/2025/05/10/yiub-m10.html
  3. https://www.foxnews.com/politics/ice-facility-democrats-stormed-holds-child-rapists-murderers-officials
  4. https://www.foxnews.com/politics/white-house-blasts-dems-crossing-line-storming-ice-facility
  5. https://www.foxnews.com/us/dem-congress-members-storm-new-jersey-ice-prison-conduct-oversight-visit-people-deserve-dignity