Dem senator says 'no doubt' Biden declined cognitively during presidency

Former President Joe Biden and First Lady Jill Biden appeared on 'The View' amidst discussions about Biden's cognitive abilities during his presidency. Senator Chris Murphy, D-Conn., voiced concerns about Biden's cognitive decline, stating it was undeniable but debated whether it affected his capacity as president. Murphy's comments reflect ongoing discussions about Biden's decision to remain in the 2024 presidential race, which some aides claim negatively impacted Vice President Harris's campaign chances. Despite these concerns, Biden defended his cognitive state during his 'The View' appearance.
The implications of Murphy's remarks highlight internal Democratic Party tensions and potential shifts in strategies following election losses attributed to a lack of compelling change offered by Biden and Harris. Murphy suggested that Biden's decision to run in 2024 was not beneficial for the party, indicating a need for introspection and strategic realignment. This discourse points to broader challenges within the Democratic Party regarding leadership and messaging, especially as they navigate post-election landscapes and future electoral contests.
RATING
The news story presents a significant topic concerning former President Biden's cognitive abilities and political impact, with potential implications for the Democratic Party. The article is timely and of public interest, engaging readers with its controversial claims. However, it lacks comprehensive evidence and diverse perspectives, relying heavily on statements from a single senator without corroborating sources. While the clarity and readability are adequate, the balance could be improved with input from medical experts and additional political figures. The story's impact and engagement potential are present, but they are limited by the lack of depth and transparency in the reporting. Overall, the article raises important questions but would benefit from a more thorough exploration of the issues at hand.
RATING DETAILS
The article presents several claims, notably those attributed to Sen. Chris Murphy and former President Joe Biden's alleged cognitive decline. The quotes from Murphy regarding Biden's cognitive abilities during his presidency and his impact on the Democratic Party are specific and attributed to Politico and Fox News Digital. However, the story lacks direct evidence or medical assessments to substantiate claims of cognitive decline, which are crucial for factual accuracy. The article also mentions attempts to reach Murphy's and Biden's offices for comment, which, while noted, does not provide additional verification of the claims. The lack of response from these offices is reported accurately but does not add to the factual support of the claims made.
The article provides a perspective that questions Biden's cognitive abilities and political decisions, primarily through Sen. Murphy's statements. However, it does not offer a counter-perspective or additional context from other Democratic leaders or experts who might support Biden's capabilities. The piece includes a rebuttal from Biden during his appearance on "The View," which helps balance the narrative slightly, yet more comprehensive viewpoints from a range of political analysts or medical experts would enhance the balance.
The article is generally clear in its language and structure, presenting the claims and responses in a straightforward manner. The narrative follows a logical progression, starting with the claims about Biden's cognitive decline and moving to the political implications. However, the inclusion of multiple topics, such as Biden's impact on the Democratic Party and Harris's campaign, could be better organized to enhance clarity and focus.
The sources referenced in the article include Politico and Fox News Digital, both of which are credible news outlets. However, the reliance on a single senator's opinion without corroborating evidence or additional authoritative sources, such as medical experts or other political figures, limits the depth of source quality. The article does not provide direct quotes from Biden's office or other officials who might offer a different perspective or confirm the claims made.
The article is somewhat transparent in disclosing its sources, such as Politico and Fox News Digital, and mentions the lack of response from Murphy's and Biden's offices. However, it does not delve into the methodology or basis for the claims of cognitive decline, nor does it explain the potential impact of these claims on Biden's political career or the Democratic Party's strategy. Greater transparency about the sources' motivations and the context of the statements would improve this aspect.
Sources
- https://spectrumlocalnews.com/tampa/weather-blog-florida-new/politics/2025/05/14/biden-book-mental-health-democrats-buttigieg-
- https://www.newstimes.com/connecticut/article/ct-murphy-biden-trump-health-age-20327613.php
- https://www.dailykos.com/stories/2025/5/14/2322395/-Murphy-says-no-doubt-Biden-suffered-cognitive-decline-while-in-office
- https://www.foxnews.com/video/6372797236112
- https://www.foxnews.com/media/schumer-democrats-dodge-questions-about-brutal-biden-revelations-looking-forward-talking-point
YOU MAY BE INTERESTED IN

"Nothing to sustain that": Biden denies reports of cognitive decline, trashes Trump on "The View"
Score 5.0
Key takeaways from Joe Biden and Jill Biden’s interview on ‘The View’
Score 7.2
Top pollster Mark Mellman warns DNC drama is quickly becoming the Democrats' brand
Score 6.2
Chuck Todd rips Chuck Schumer over Biden decline cover-up: ‘As responsible as anybody else’
Score 6.2