Catholic Church denounces online sale of saint-to-be's relics

Apnews - Apr 5th, 2025

The Catholic Church has initiated an investigation with Italian police regarding the online sale of purported relics belonging to Carlo Acutis, the soon-to-be-canonized millennial saint. The Diocese of Assisi reported that supposed locks of Acutis’ hair were being auctioned for over 2,000 euros before the listings were removed. Bishop Domenico Sorrentino condemned the sale as a grave offense against religious belief, and church officials emphasized that any form of commerce involving faith is considered sinful. The scandal has unfolded just weeks before Acutis is officially declared a saint at a ceremony in front of St. Peter’s Basilica.

This development underscores the heightened interest and devotion surrounding Acutis, who has already attracted millions of pilgrims to Assisi. Acutis, a tech-savvy teenager who died in 2006, is celebrated for his deep faith and dedication to the Eucharist. As he becomes a symbol for young Catholics, the Church grapples with balancing tradition with modern challenges, such as unauthorized relic sales. The incident also raises broader questions about the commercialization of religious artifacts and the ethical responsibilities of those who hold them in reverence.

St. Peter’s Basilica Catholic Church Vatican Investigation Faith Carlo Acutis Relics Canonization Commerce

Story submitted by Fairstory

RATING

8.2

Fair Story

Consider it well-founded

The article effectively reports on the Catholic Church's response to the unauthorized sale of Carlo Acutis' relics, providing accurate and timely information on this issue. It draws from credible sources and presents a balanced view, though it could benefit from additional perspectives. The narrative is clear and engaging, with a logical structure that enhances readability. While the topic is of public interest and timely, the article could explore the controversy more deeply by including diverse viewpoints and further exploration of the ethical implications. Overall, the story is a well-rounded piece that informs readers about an important religious and ethical issue.

Accuracy

The story accurately reports on the Catholic Church's investigation into the unauthorized sale of Carlo Acutis' relics, aligning with other sources confirming the investigation by Italian authorities. The claim about the prohibition of relic sales under Catholic Church law is precise and consistent with canon law. The details about Carlo Acutis' background, beatification, and upcoming canonization are verifiable and match public records and previous reports. However, the authenticity of the relics sold online remains unconfirmed, which is a crucial aspect needing further verification.

Balance

The article presents the perspective of the Catholic Church regarding the sale of relics, emphasizing its prohibition and the spiritual significance of relics. It includes quotes from church officials and pilgrims, providing a range of views on the issue. However, the article could benefit from including perspectives from those involved in the sale or external experts on religious artifacts, which would offer a more comprehensive view of the situation.

Clarity

The article is clear and well-structured, with a logical flow that guides the reader through the issue of relic sales and the church's response. The language is neutral and accessible, making the complex topic understandable for a general audience. The inclusion of direct quotes and specific details about Carlo Acutis' life and canonization process adds depth and clarity to the narrative.

Source quality

The article relies on credible sources, including direct quotes from church officials and references to official actions by the Diocese of Assisi. The Associated Press is a reputable news organization, enhancing the story's credibility. However, the article could improve by providing more detailed attribution for some claims, such as the specifics of the Italian police investigation.

Transparency

The article is transparent in its reporting, clearly outlining the church's stance on relic sales and the actions taken by the Diocese of Assisi. It discloses the basis for its claims with quotes from relevant authorities. However, it lacks detailed information on the methodology of the investigation or the process of relic authentication, which would enhance transparency.