Biden White House gave Trump, Pence cellphones to FBI as part of agency’s ‘gotcha scheme’ probing 2020 election

In May 2022, the Biden White House transferred government cellphones belonging to former President Donald Trump and former Vice President Mike Pence to the FBI as part of an investigation into the aftermath of the 2020 election. The FBI, without needing a warrant for the physical phones, later sought a search warrant to access the data. The investigation, known as 'Arctic Frost,' was initiated by former FBI agent Timothy Thibault, who allegedly broke protocol by involving Trump without proper authorization. Whistleblower disclosures have exposed these actions, revealing the investigation's aggressive nature against Trump and his supporters.
The revelations have prompted Senate Judiciary Committee Chairman Chuck Grassley and Senate Subcommittee on Investigations Chairman Ron Johnson to demand accountability from the FBI and DOJ. They made the whistleblower documents public, highlighting the need for transparency and professionalism within these agencies. The investigation was later transferred to special counsel Jack Smith, who charged Trump with various offenses. However, Trump was acquitted, and questions about the investigation's legitimacy and political bias continue to linger, with calls for detailed records and expenditures related to the 'Arctic Frost' probe.
RATING
The article effectively covers a timely and controversial topic, providing detailed information about the investigation involving high-profile political figures. It draws on credible sources, such as whistleblower disclosures and statements from Senators Grassley and Johnson, to support its claims. However, the piece could benefit from a more balanced perspective by including responses from the FBI and the Biden administration, as well as insights from independent experts. While the article is generally clear and engaging, it lacks transparency in some areas, such as the methodology behind the disclosures and potential biases in the reporting. Overall, the article is a compelling read with the potential to influence public opinion and spark meaningful discussions about governmental accountability and transparency.
RATING DETAILS
The article presents several factual claims, such as the Biden White House turning over Trump and Pence’s cellphones to the FBI and the initiation of the 'Arctic Frost' investigation by Timothy Thibault. These claims are largely supported by sources cited within the article, including whistleblower disclosures and statements from Senators Grassley and Johnson. However, the assertion that the investigation lacked sufficient predication and was driven by political bias requires further verification. The article accurately reports on the procedural aspects of acquiring the phones and the subsequent legal steps taken, such as the drafting of search warrants. Nonetheless, the piece could benefit from additional corroboration from independent sources to strengthen its factual basis.
The article predominantly presents a narrative critical of the FBI and the Biden administration, focusing on alleged misconduct and political bias in the investigation. It heavily relies on statements from Republican Senators Grassley and Johnson, which may skew the perspective towards a partisan viewpoint. The piece lacks counterpoints or responses from the FBI or the Biden administration, which could provide a more balanced view. Including perspectives from legal experts or Democrats could enhance the article's balance by providing alternative interpretations of the events described.
The article is generally clear and well-structured, with a logical flow that guides the reader through the sequence of events. It effectively uses subheadings and quotes to break down complex legal and procedural information. However, some areas could benefit from simplification, especially when discussing legal processes and the implications of the whistleblower disclosures. The tone is neutral in language but implicitly critical in content, which may affect how the information is perceived by different audiences.
The article cites whistleblower disclosures and statements from Senators Grassley and Johnson as primary sources, which are credible but may carry inherent biases due to their political affiliations. The lack of direct commentary from the FBI, the White House, or independent experts limits the diversity of sources. The reliance on Fox News Digital as the sole reporting outlet may also affect the perceived impartiality, as it is known for its conservative leanings. Including a broader range of sources could improve the report's credibility and reliability.
The article provides some transparency by citing whistleblower disclosures and specific dates related to the investigation. However, it does not sufficiently explain the methodology behind these disclosures or how they were obtained and verified. The absence of direct quotes from the primary individuals involved, such as FBI officials or White House representatives, reduces transparency. Additionally, the article does not disclose any potential conflicts of interest or biases that might affect the reporting, which would be beneficial for readers to understand the context fully.
Sources
- https://www.foxnews.com/politics/biden-white-house-turned-over-trump-pence-government-cell-phones-fbi-part-anti-trump-elector-case
- https://www.washingtontimes.com/news/2025/mar/14/biden-white-house-gave-fbi-trump-pence-cellphones-2020-election-probe/
- https://www.fox8tv.com/biden-white-house-turned-over-trump-pence-government-cellphones-to-fbi-as-part-of-anti-trump-agents-case/
YOU MAY BE INTERESTED IN

Special Counsel Jack Smith resigns after 2-year stint at Department of Justice
Score 6.2
Former CISA director Chris Krebs vows to fight back against Trump-ordered federal investigation
Score 7.6
Gary Shapley, whistleblower IRS agent who investigated Hunter Biden, expected to be named agency’s acting chief
Score 6.0
Did DOGE take sensitive labor data?
Score 5.0