At least 12 passengers dead after jumping onto tracks over train fire alert in India

ABC News - Jan 22nd, 2025
Open on ABC News

At least 12 passengers were killed and six injured in a tragic incident in Maharashtra, western India, when they jumped from the halted Pushpak Express train after rumors of a fire spread among passengers. The victims were struck by the approaching Karnataka Express on an adjacent track. The accident occurred near Pardhade station, 410 kilometers southwest of Mumbai. Initial investigations suggest sparks in a coach due to a 'hot axle' or 'brake-binding' caused panic, leading to the emergency chain being pulled and passengers disembarking onto the tracks.

This incident highlights ongoing safety challenges in India's vast railway network, despite government efforts to modernize the system. The Indian railways, the largest under single management globally, have a history of accidents, with a recent major crash in 2023 resulting in over 280 deaths. Prime Minister Narendra Modi's administration is focusing on upgrading the outdated infrastructure to prevent such tragedies, underscoring the importance of safety in the world's most populous nation with a burgeoning railway system.

Story submitted by Fairstory

RATING

7.6
Fair Story
Consider it well-founded

The article provides a factual and timely report on a tragic train accident in India, with accurate details about the incident and context about broader rail safety issues. It effectively uses credible sources but could benefit from a wider range of perspectives, such as passenger accounts, to enhance depth and engagement. While the article is clear and easy to read, it lacks transparency about the information-gathering process and does not explore the potential causes of the sparks in detail. Overall, it serves as a reliable source of information but could have a greater impact with additional investigative elements and personal narratives.

RATING DETAILS

8
Accuracy

The story accurately reports the key facts of the train accident, including the location, number of fatalities and injuries, and the circumstances leading to the incident. The details about the accident occurring near the Pardhade railroad station in Maharashtra and involving the Pushpak Express train align with other sources. The number of casualties and the description of the panic among passengers due to sparks are consistent with other reports. However, the exact cause of the sparks, whether 'hot axle' or 'brake-binding,' remains speculative and needs further verification. Additionally, while the story mentions the broader context of rail safety issues in India, it does not provide specific data to support the claim of hundreds of accidents occurring annually.

7
Balance

The article provides a relatively balanced view of the incident by including perspectives from different stakeholders, such as the police and railway officials. It mentions the broader context of rail safety in India and government efforts to modernize the railway network. However, it lacks direct quotes or perspectives from passengers or eyewitnesses, which could have added depth to the narrative. The focus is primarily on the facts and official statements, which can limit the range of viewpoints presented.

9
Clarity

The article is well-structured and uses clear, concise language to convey the facts of the incident. The narrative flows logically, starting with the key details of the accident and then providing context about rail safety in India. The tone is neutral and factual, making it easy for readers to understand the information presented. However, the inclusion of technical terms like 'hot axle' and 'brake-binding' without further explanation might confuse some readers unfamiliar with railway terminology.

8
Source quality

The article cites reputable sources such as the Press Trust of India and includes statements from a police officer and a railway spokesman. These sources are credible and relevant to the incident, providing a reliable basis for the reported information. However, the article could benefit from a broader range of sources, such as independent experts or passenger accounts, to enhance the depth and reliability of the coverage.

6
Transparency

The article provides clear information about the sources of its claims, such as the Press Trust of India and statements from officials. However, it lacks transparency regarding the methodology of how information was gathered, such as whether journalists were on the scene or if the information was obtained through press releases. Additionally, there is no disclosure of potential conflicts of interest or limitations of the reported information.

Sources

  1. https://www.ndtv.com/india-news/12-passengers-jump-out-of-train-in-panic-as-men-operate-fire-extinguisher-6313193
  2. https://www.business-standard.com/india-news/jalgaon-tragedy-11-dead-as-passengers-jump-off-train-after-fire-rumour-125012201451_1.html
  3. https://www.hindustantimes.com/india-news/11-dead-after-jumping-off-pushpak-express-over-fire-scare-hit-by-another-train-101737563953497.html
  4. https://timesofindia.indiatimes.com/india/many-killed-as-train-runs-over-passengers-on-tracks-in-maharashtras-jalgaon-district-what-we-know-so-far/articleshow/117457077.cms
  5. https://abcnews.go.com/International/200-killed-hundreds-injured-train-crash-india/story?id=99801876