Arizona was 'big part of my life,' says National Cathedral bishop who pleaded with Trump

Yahoo! News - Apr 20th, 2025
Open on Yahoo! News

In a striking moment at the Washington National Cathedral, Bishop Mariann Edgar Budde delivered a poignant sermon directly addressing President Donald Trump, urging compassion for migrants and transgender individuals. Her remarks, broadcast nationally, received a sharp response from Trump, who criticized her on Truth Social. Budde's plea was emblematic of resistance to Trump’s policies in his second term. Her advocacy for marginalized communities has deep roots, dating back over four decades to her time as a missionary in southern Arizona, where she worked closely with migrants and refugees.

Budde's sermon resonated with many, symbolizing a broader call for empathy in American society. Her impactful message also highlighted the role of women in religious leadership, a relatively recent development in the Episcopal Church. Support from fellow clergy, such as Bishops Jennifer Reddall and Deborah Hutterer, underscores Budde's influence and the growing acknowledgment of women's voices in faith communities. Her Arizona experiences and advocacy work have significantly shaped her ministry, emphasizing mercy and humanity in societal and political discourse.

Story submitted by Fairstory

RATING

6.8
Fair Story
Consider it well-founded

The article provides a compelling narrative focused on Bishop Mariann Edgar Budde's sermon challenging President Trump, set against the backdrop of her personal history and advocacy for marginalized communities. It excels in accuracy, clarity, and public interest, offering a well-structured account that is both informative and engaging. However, it could benefit from greater balance and source quality by including a wider range of perspectives and more robust sourcing. Transparency in methodology and context would further strengthen the story's credibility. Overall, the article effectively highlights significant social and political issues, making it a valuable contribution to public discourse.

RATING DETAILS

8
Accuracy

The article provides a detailed account of Bishop Mariann Edgar Budde's background, her sermon directed at President Trump, and the political context of her statements. The facts about Budde's education, her work in Arizona, and her role as the first female bishop of the Washington diocese are consistent with available biographical data. The description of her sermon and Trump's reaction also aligns with known events. However, some claims, such as the specific content of Trump's executive orders and the details of Kilmar Abrego Garcia's deportation, would benefit from direct source citations to ensure full accuracy. Overall, the story maintains a high level of factual accuracy with minor areas needing additional verification.

7
Balance

The story largely presents Bishop Budde's perspective and the impact of her sermon on the public and other clergy members. While it includes Trump's reaction to her sermon, it does not provide a broader range of viewpoints, such as those from Trump's supporters or other political analysts. The narrative focuses on Budde's advocacy and influence, which might overshadow alternative interpretations or criticisms of her actions. Including more diverse perspectives could enhance the balance of the article.

8
Clarity

The article is well-structured and uses clear, concise language to convey the story of Bishop Budde and her sermon. The chronological presentation of events and the inclusion of direct quotes from Budde and Trump help maintain a logical flow. The tone is neutral and informative, making the content accessible to a broad audience. Minor improvements could be made in explaining complex political contexts to enhance overall clarity.

6
Source quality

The article references credible sources such as The Arizona Republic and mentions public figures like Bishop Budde and President Trump. However, it lacks direct citations from primary sources or official records that could strengthen the reliability of specific claims, particularly regarding political and legal aspects. The absence of a variety of sources, such as academic experts or independent analysts, limits the depth of the report. Better attribution to specific statements and events would improve source quality.

5
Transparency

The article provides context for Budde's actions and her historical background, which aids in understanding her motivations. However, it lacks transparency regarding the methodology of gathering information, such as interviews or document reviews. The story does not disclose any potential conflicts of interest or biases that might affect its impartiality. Greater transparency in how information was obtained and any editorial considerations would enhance the article's credibility.

Sources

  1. https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Mariann_Budde
  2. https://www.washingtonian.com/2014/07/03/what-made-me-mariann-edgar-budde/
  3. http://episcopalelections.com/elections/minnesota/nominees/BuddeBio.pdf
  4. https://episcopalnewsservice.org/2011/11/14/mariann-budde-consecrated-as-washingtons-ninth-bishop/
  5. https://www.instagram.com/feminist/reel/DFG7awjtW3o/