Are planes crashing more often?

After a wave of high-profile air disasters, including a tragic collision in Washington DC and alarming near-misses circulating on social media, US Transport Secretary Sean Duffy addressed public fear, citing these events as 'very unique'. Despite the recent incidents, data from the National Transportation Safety Board (NTSB) and International Civil Aviation Organisation (ICAO) indicates a long-term decline in air accidents over the past two decades, with January 2025 showing fewer incidents compared to previous years.
Experts emphasize that the increased visibility of air disasters on social media is amplifying public concern, but the overall safety of air travel remains high. Historical data reveals that the number of accidents and fatalities per million plane departures has decreased globally. Experts also highlight that comprehensive investigations and advanced training simulators have enhanced pilot preparedness and safety protocols. Despite recent concerns, air travel continues to be the safest mode of transportation compared to road travel, as highlighted by US Department of Transportation statistics.
RATING
The article provides a comprehensive analysis of the perceived increase in air travel accidents, effectively countering public misconceptions with factual data and expert insights. Its strengths lie in the use of credible sources, balanced perspectives, and clear presentation of information. The article addresses a timely and relevant issue, contributing positively to public discourse on aviation safety. However, there is room for improvement in transparency regarding data analysis and engagement through interactive elements. Overall, the story is a well-rounded piece that informs and reassures readers about the safety of air travel.
RATING DETAILS
The story accurately reports on the perceived increase in air travel accidents and provides a detailed analysis of statistical data to counter these perceptions. It cites credible sources like the National Transportation Safety Board (NTSB) and the International Civil Aviation Organisation (ICAO) to support its claims. The factual claims about specific incidents, such as the mid-air collision in Washington DC and the Toronto landing incident, are presented with precise details. However, the story's use of terms like 'very unique' to describe the recent spate of accidents could be misleading without further context. The story effectively distinguishes between perception driven by social media and actual statistical trends, which is crucial for factual accuracy.
The article presents a balanced view by acknowledging both the public's growing concern over air safety and the statistical evidence showing a downward trend in accidents. It includes perspectives from various experts, such as Ismo Aaltonen and Marco Chan, who provide insights into why the perception of increased accidents might not reflect reality. However, the article could improve balance by including perspectives from aviation industry representatives or consumer safety advocates to provide a more comprehensive view of the issue.
The article is well-structured and presents information in a logical flow, making it easy for readers to follow the argument. The language is clear and precise, avoiding jargon that could confuse readers. The use of subheadings and quotes from experts helps to break down complex information into digestible parts. However, the article could improve clarity by providing more context for terms like 'very unique' to avoid potential misunderstandings.
The story uses high-quality sources, including data from the NTSB and ICAO, which are authoritative bodies in aviation safety. It also references experts like Prof Sir David Spiegelhalter and Ismo Aaltonen, whose credentials lend credibility to the analysis. The variety of sources, including statistics and expert opinions, enhances the reliability of the information presented. The article's reliance on reputable and diverse sources strengthens its overall credibility.
The article is transparent in its use of data and expert opinions, clearly attributing information to specific sources like the NTSB and ICAO. It explains the methodology behind the statistical analysis, such as the definition of an aircraft accident by ICAO. However, the article could enhance transparency by detailing how the data was analyzed and any potential limitations in the data sets used. Overall, the transparency of the article is strong, but there is room for improvement in explaining the methodology.
Sources
YOU MAY BE INTERESTED IN

Crisis immediately greets Duffy as he takes over Transportation Department | CNN Politics
Score 6.2
TechCrunch Mobility: Slate’s ‘transformer’ EV truck breaks cover and Tesla’s dueling realities
Score 6.2
NTSB investigating after experimental plane crashes at Langley Air Force Base
Score 5.8
Trump & Co. must put the brakes on idle threats and keep its vow to end congestion tax
Score 5.6